Have any feedback, problems or suggestions? Feel free to reach out:
| In game: | You may find me playing Mantid on the Emerald ocean |
| Email: | site@ypp.mantid.org |
| Discord: | discord.gg/cGrvvvR7vm |
Love what I'm doing? I accept donations but please don't feel obliged
You could /tip or /pay Mantid (on Emerald); or even consider real money and Buy me a Coffee
 | |||||||||||||||||||
 |
 |
 |
 |
||||||||||||||||
 |
|||||||||||||||||||
| Pirate | Obtainable | Historical | Total | Updated | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1st | Justu (Emerald) | 482 | 176 | 658 | 2 days ago | 🔍 |
|
| 2nd | Scottys (Meridian) | 470 | 206 | 676 | 16 hours ago | 🔍 |
|
| 3rd | Tzz (Emerald) | 463 | 126 | 589 | 1 hour ago | 🔍 |
|
| 4th | Iuffy (Meridian) | 442 | 280 | 722 | 5 days ago | 🔍 |
|
| 5th | Diletto (Cerulean) | 432 | 279 | 711 | 18 days ago | 🔍 |
|
| 6th | Masters (Emerald) | 424 | 407 | 831 | 10 days ago | 🔍 |
|
| 7th | Sonicbang (Emerald) | 410 | 125 | 535 | 2 days ago | 🔍 |
|
| 8th | Multibella (Emerald) | 407 | 233 | 640 | 2 days ago | 🔍 |
|
| 9th | Fourteen (Cerulean) | 399 | 475 | 874 | 15 days ago | 🔍 |
|
| 10th | Tosl (Emerald) | 399 | 72 | 471 | 8 minutes ago | 🔍 |
|
| 11th | Rudis (Emerald) | 395 | 201 | 596 | 10 days ago | 🔍 |
|
| 12th | Helium (Emerald) | 391 | 151 | 542 | 9 minutes ago | 🔍 |
|
| 13th | Crip (Cerulean) | 388 | 348 | 736 | 30 days ago | 🔍 |
|
| 14th | Missyfiercer (Emerald) | 388 | 195 | 583 | 10 days ago | 🔍 |
|
| 15th | Snrm (Emerald) | 386 | 155 | 541 | 4 days ago | 🔍 |
|
| 16th | Dirtybowdy (Emerald) | 384 | 111 | 495 | 9 days ago | 🔍 |
|
| 17th | Adnerb (Emerald) | 383 | 259 | 642 | 10 days ago | 🔍 |
|
| 18th | Delores (Emerald) | 381 | 516 | 897 | 9 days ago | 🔍 |
|
| 19th | Sherbetlemon (Cerulean) | 378 | 484 | 862 | 1 month ago | 🔍 |
|
| 20th | Ilkko (Meridian) | 378 | 248 | 626 | 1 day ago | 🔍 |
|
| 21st | Princessmg (Emerald) | 377 | 254 | 631 | 1 month ago | 🔍 |
|
| 22nd | Metaalmeisje (Cerulean) | 374 | 327 | 701 | 1 month ago | 🔍 |
|
| 23rd | Skeletoness (Emerald) | 368 | 154 | 522 | 11 days ago | 🔍 |
|
| 24th | Shooshy (Emerald) | 366 | 192 | 558 | 1 month ago | 🔍 |
|
| 25th | Barbecul (Emerald) | 366 | 146 | 512 | 2 months ago | 🔍 |
|
| 26th | Tuhero (Emerald) | 366 | 76 | 442 | 23 days ago | 🔍 |
|
| 27th | Zingman (Cerulean) | 364 | 500 | 864 | 1 month ago | 🔍 |
|
| 28th | Missmiauw (Emerald) | 362 | 244 | 606 | 5 days ago | 🔍 |
|
| 29th | Fooqueso (Cerulean) | 359 | 222 | 581 | 18 days ago | 🔍 |
|
| 30th | Emiya (Cerulean) | 357 | 301 | 658 | 30 days ago | 🔍 |
|
| 31st | Ylisse (Emerald) | 357 | 117 | 474 | 1 day ago | 🔍 |
|
| 32nd | Aquaneer (Emerald) | 357 | 58 | 415 | 1 day ago | 🔍 |
|
| 33rd | Cpntook (Cerulean) | 356 | 368 | 724 | 1 month ago | 🔍 |
|
| 34th | Umami (Emerald) | 356 | 117 | 473 | 1 month ago | 🔍 |
|
| 35th | Galantis (Emerald) | 356 | 67 | 423 | 4 days ago | 🔍 |
|
| 36th | Zocpiare (Emerald) | 352 | 246 | 598 | 2 days ago | 🔍 |
|
| 37th | Zebuline (Emerald) | 351 | 144 | 495 | 2 days ago | 🔍 |
|
| 38th | Felismajor (Emerald) | 350 | 390 | 740 | 2 days ago | 🔍 |
|
| 39th | Lolomokika (Emerald) | 350 | 166 | 516 | 3 days ago | 🔍 |
|
| 40th | Elsol (Emerald) | 349 | 226 | 575 | 3 days ago | 🔍 |
|
| 41st | Terrorted (Emerald) | 349 | 176 | 525 | 3 days ago | 🔍 |
|
| 42nd | Emerlaus (Emerald) | 347 | 257 | 604 | 3 days ago | 🔍 |
|
| 43rd | Bealotus (Cerulean) | 346 | 480 | 826 | 18 days ago | 🔍 |
|
| 44th | Bluerain (Emerald) | 346 | 209 | 555 | 3 days ago | 🔍 |
|
| 45th | Orchidee (Cerulean) | 343 | 492 | 835 | 1 month ago | 🔍 |
|
| 46th | Westly (Meridian) | 343 | 182 | 525 | 8 months ago | 🔍 |
|
| 47th | Buzzybear (Emerald) | 343 | 168 | 511 | 3 days ago | 🔍 |
|
| 48th | Dumpo (Emerald) | 342 | 256 | 598 | 3 days ago | 🔍 |
|
| 49th | Crabbycrank (Cerulean) | 339 | 502 | 841 | 1 month ago | 🔍 |
|
| 50th | Cithara (Emerald) | 339 | 302 | 641 | 2 days ago | 🔍 |
|
| 51st | Ttoonnyy (Cerulean) | 337 | 424 | 761 | 1 month ago | 🔍 |
|
| 52nd | Bookly (Emerald) | 337 | 224 | 561 | 2 days ago | 🔍 |
|
| 53rd | Esaidra (Meridian) | 336 | 359 | 695 | 4 months ago | 🔍 |
|
| 54th | Shar (Emerald) | 336 | 232 | 568 | 5 days ago | 🔍 |
|
| 55th | Hugoboss (Emerald) | 336 | 144 | 480 | 6 days ago | 🔍 |
|
| 56th | Kriscri (Cerulean) | 335 | 485 | 820 | 1 month ago | 🔍 |
|
| 57th | Garibaldi (Cerulean) | 334 | 445 | 779 | 1 month ago | 🔍 |
|
| 58th | Auraluna (Cerulean) | 333 | 270 | 603 | 1 month ago | 🔍 |
|
| 59th | Gagundss (Meridian) | 333 | 210 | 543 | 5 months ago | 🔍 |
|
| 60th | Pandayay (Emerald) | 333 | 31 | 364 | 3 days ago | 🔍 |
|
| 61st | Cristyy (Emerald) | 331 | 185 | 516 | 6 days ago | 🔍 |
|
| 62nd | Mwynn (Emerald) | 330 | 173 | 503 | 6 days ago | 🔍 |
|
| 63rd | Canadagoose (Emerald) | 330 | 83 | 413 | 1 month ago | 🔍 |
|
| 64th | Scrib (Emerald) | 330 | 72 | 402 | 1 month ago | 🔍 |
|
| 65th | Starsailors (Cerulean) | 329 | 442 | 771 | 1 month ago | 🔍 |
|
| 66th | Senga (Emerald) | 329 | 385 | 714 | 1 month ago | 🔍 |
|
| 67th | Nathaliee (Meridian) | 329 | 138 | 467 | 1 day ago | 🔍 |
|
| 68th | Owlwhisperer (Meridian) | 328 | 455 | 783 | 1 month ago | 🔍 |
|
| 69th | Zeche (Emerald) | 328 | 126 | 454 | 16 days ago | 🔍 |
|
| 70th | Robee (Emerald) | 327 | 364 | 691 | 2 months ago | 🔍 |
|
| 71st | Lakabars (Emerald) | 327 | 244 | 571 | 2 months ago | 🔍 |
|
| 72nd | Zelnok (Cerulean) | 327 | 196 | 523 | 1 month ago | 🔍 |
|
| 73rd | Moonthefr (Emerald) | 327 | 159 | 486 | 1 month ago | 🔍 |
|
| 74th | Radway (Emerald) | 327 | 149 | 476 | 1 month ago | 🔍 |
|
| 75th | Rock (Emerald) | 327 | 107 | 434 | 1 day ago | 🔍 |
|
| 76th | Eveiemarie (Cerulean) | 325 | 380 | 705 | 1 month ago | 🔍 |
|
| 77th | Twoknives (Meridian) | 325 | 338 | 663 | 18 days ago | 🔍 |
|
| 78th | Fidy (Emerald) | 325 | 77 | 402 | 2 months ago | 🔍 |
|
| 79th | Solame (Meridian) | 324 | 200 | 524 | 5 months ago | 🔍 |
|
| 80th | Squawks (Emerald) | 324 | 117 | 441 | 1 month ago | 🔍 |
|
| 81st | Xliberatellx (Emerald) | 324 | 111 | 435 | 4 months ago | 🔍 |
|
| 82nd | Nipnipchin (Emerald) | 324 | 101 | 425 | 2 months ago | 🔍 |
|
| 83rd | Capitus (Emerald) | 324 | 96 | 420 | 2 months ago | 🔍 |
|
| 84th | Gulfstream (Emerald) | 323 | 256 | 579 | 2 months ago | 🔍 |
|
| 85th | Catzie (Emerald) | 322 | 319 | 641 | 4 months ago | 🔍 |
|
| 86th | Velryba (Emerald) | 321 | 489 | 810 | 4 months ago | 🔍 |
|
| 87th | Irig (Meridian) | 321 | 182 | 503 | 1 month ago | 🔍 |
|
| 88th | Electrablack (Emerald) | 321 | 162 | 483 | 30 days ago | 🔍 |
|
| 89th | Hfsktr (Emerald) | 320 | 231 | 551 | 30 days ago | 🔍 |
|
| 90th | Tommyr (Emerald) | 319 | 342 | 661 | 1 month ago | 🔍 |
|
| 91st | Fearlessjan (Emerald) | 319 | 282 | 601 | 4 months ago | 🔍 |
|
| 92nd | Ryujin (Cerulean) | 319 | 253 | 572 | 1 month ago | 🔍 |
|
| 93rd | Kampfdackel (Emerald) | 318 | 157 | 475 | 2 months ago | 🔍 |
|
| 94th | Logictechno (Emerald) | 318 | 152 | 470 | 5 days ago | 🔍 |
|
| 95th | Cheryll (Emerald) | 317 | 444 | 761 | 4 months ago | 🔍 |
|
| 96th | Gunray (Meridian) | 317 | 322 | 639 | 4 months ago | 🔍 |
|
| 97th | Djames (Emerald) | 317 | 248 | 565 | 4 months ago | 🔍 |
|
| 98th | Codefish (Emerald) | 317 | 224 | 541 | 4 months ago | 🔍 |
|
| 99th | Bisca (Emerald) | 317 | 123 | 440 | 2 months ago | 🔍 |
|
| 100th | Technitium (Emerald) | 317 | 104 | 421 | 1 month ago | 🔍 |
|
| 1st | Justu | 482 | 176 | 658 | 2 days ago | 🔍 |
|
| 2nd | Tzz | 463 | 126 | 589 | 1 hour ago | 🔍 |
|
| 3rd | Masters | 424 | 407 | 831 | 10 days ago | 🔍 |
|
| 4th | Sonicbang | 410 | 125 | 535 | 2 days ago | 🔍 |
|
| 5th | Multibella | 407 | 233 | 640 | 2 days ago | 🔍 |
|
| 6th | Tosl | 399 | 72 | 471 | 8 minutes ago | 🔍 |
|
| 7th | Rudis | 395 | 201 | 596 | 10 days ago | 🔍 |
|
| 8th | Helium | 391 | 151 | 542 | 9 minutes ago | 🔍 |
|
| 9th | Missyfiercer | 388 | 195 | 583 | 10 days ago | 🔍 |
|
| 10th | Snrm | 386 | 155 | 541 | 4 days ago | 🔍 |
|
| 11th | Dirtybowdy | 384 | 111 | 495 | 9 days ago | 🔍 |
|
| 12th | Adnerb | 383 | 259 | 642 | 10 days ago | 🔍 |
|
| 13th | Delores | 381 | 516 | 897 | 9 days ago | 🔍 |
|
| 14th | Princessmg | 377 | 254 | 631 | 1 month ago | 🔍 |
|
| 15th | Skeletoness | 368 | 154 | 522 | 11 days ago | 🔍 |
|
| 16th | Shooshy | 366 | 192 | 558 | 1 month ago | 🔍 |
|
| 17th | Barbecul | 366 | 146 | 512 | 2 months ago | 🔍 |
|
| 18th | Tuhero | 366 | 76 | 442 | 23 days ago | 🔍 |
|
| 19th | Missmiauw | 362 | 244 | 606 | 5 days ago | 🔍 |
|
| 20th | Ylisse | 357 | 117 | 474 | 1 day ago | 🔍 |
|
| 21st | Aquaneer | 357 | 58 | 415 | 1 day ago | 🔍 |
|
| 22nd | Umami | 356 | 117 | 473 | 1 month ago | 🔍 |
|
| 23rd | Galantis | 356 | 67 | 423 | 4 days ago | 🔍 |
|
| 24th | Zocpiare | 352 | 246 | 598 | 2 days ago | 🔍 |
|
| 25th | Zebuline | 351 | 144 | 495 | 2 days ago | 🔍 |
|
| 26th | Felismajor | 350 | 390 | 740 | 2 days ago | 🔍 |
|
| 27th | Lolomokika | 350 | 166 | 516 | 3 days ago | 🔍 |
|
| 28th | Elsol | 349 | 226 | 575 | 3 days ago | 🔍 |
|
| 29th | Terrorted | 349 | 176 | 525 | 3 days ago | 🔍 |
|
| 30th | Emerlaus | 347 | 257 | 604 | 3 days ago | 🔍 |
|
| 31st | Bluerain | 346 | 209 | 555 | 3 days ago | 🔍 |
|
| 32nd | Buzzybear | 343 | 168 | 511 | 3 days ago | 🔍 |
|
| 33rd | Dumpo | 342 | 256 | 598 | 3 days ago | 🔍 |
|
| 34th | Cithara | 339 | 302 | 641 | 2 days ago | 🔍 |
|
| 35th | Bookly | 337 | 224 | 561 | 2 days ago | 🔍 |
|
| 36th | Shar | 336 | 232 | 568 | 5 days ago | 🔍 |
|
| 37th | Hugoboss | 336 | 144 | 480 | 6 days ago | 🔍 |
|
| 38th | Pandayay | 333 | 31 | 364 | 3 days ago | 🔍 |
|
| 39th | Cristyy | 331 | 185 | 516 | 6 days ago | 🔍 |
|
| 40th | Mwynn | 330 | 173 | 503 | 6 days ago | 🔍 |
|
| 41st | Canadagoose | 330 | 83 | 413 | 1 month ago | 🔍 |
|
| 42nd | Scrib | 330 | 72 | 402 | 1 month ago | 🔍 |
|
| 43rd | Senga | 329 | 385 | 714 | 1 month ago | 🔍 |
|
| 44th | Zeche | 328 | 126 | 454 | 16 days ago | 🔍 |
|
| 45th | Robee | 327 | 364 | 691 | 2 months ago | 🔍 |
|
| 46th | Lakabars | 327 | 244 | 571 | 2 months ago | 🔍 |
|
| 47th | Moonthefr | 327 | 159 | 486 | 1 month ago | 🔍 |
|
| 48th | Radway | 327 | 149 | 476 | 1 month ago | 🔍 |
|
| 49th | Rock | 327 | 107 | 434 | 1 day ago | 🔍 |
|
| 50th | Fidy | 325 | 77 | 402 | 2 months ago | 🔍 |
|
| 51st | Squawks | 324 | 117 | 441 | 1 month ago | 🔍 |
|
| 52nd | Xliberatellx | 324 | 111 | 435 | 4 months ago | 🔍 |
|
| 53rd | Nipnipchin | 324 | 101 | 425 | 2 months ago | 🔍 |
|
| 54th | Capitus | 324 | 96 | 420 | 2 months ago | 🔍 |
|
| 55th | Gulfstream | 323 | 256 | 579 | 2 months ago | 🔍 |
|
| 56th | Catzie | 322 | 319 | 641 | 4 months ago | 🔍 |
|
| 57th | Velryba | 321 | 489 | 810 | 4 months ago | 🔍 |
|
| 58th | Electrablack | 321 | 162 | 483 | 30 days ago | 🔍 |
|
| 59th | Hfsktr | 320 | 231 | 551 | 30 days ago | 🔍 |
|
| 60th | Tommyr | 319 | 342 | 661 | 1 month ago | 🔍 |
|
| 61st | Fearlessjan | 319 | 282 | 601 | 4 months ago | 🔍 |
|
| 62nd | Kampfdackel | 318 | 157 | 475 | 2 months ago | 🔍 |
|
| 63rd | Logictechno | 318 | 152 | 470 | 5 days ago | 🔍 |
|
| 64th | Cheryll | 317 | 444 | 761 | 4 months ago | 🔍 |
|
| 65th | Djames | 317 | 248 | 565 | 4 months ago | 🔍 |
|
| 66th | Codefish | 317 | 224 | 541 | 4 months ago | 🔍 |
|
| 67th | Bisca | 317 | 123 | 440 | 2 months ago | 🔍 |
|
| 68th | Technitium | 317 | 104 | 421 | 1 month ago | 🔍 |
|
| 69th | Hozier | 317 | 95 | 412 | 4 months ago | 🔍 |
|
| 70th | Akexrawr | 317 | 51 | 368 | 16 hours ago | 🔍 |
|
| 71st | Squishat | 316 | 168 | 484 | 1 month ago | 🔍 |
|
| 72nd | Mdre | 316 | 73 | 389 | 4 days ago | 🔍 |
|
| 73rd | Pegasiswolf | 315 | 242 | 557 | 1 month ago | 🔍 |
|
| 74th | Klady | 315 | 236 | 551 | 6 days ago | 🔍 |
|
| 75th | Kikinoki | 315 | 186 | 501 | 2 months ago | 🔍 |
|
| 76th | Kushlorde | 315 | 137 | 452 | 23 days ago | 🔍 |
|
| 77th | Legendu | 314 | 116 | 430 | 1 month ago | 🔍 |
|
| 78th | Melany | 313 | 202 | 515 | 2 months ago | 🔍 |
|
| 79th | Staycr | 313 | 130 | 443 | 1 month ago | 🔍 |
|
| 80th | Knecht | 313 | 104 | 417 | 1 month ago | 🔍 |
|
| 81st | Dutchess | 311 | 196 | 507 | 2 months ago | 🔍 |
|
| 82nd | Starz | 311 | 186 | 497 | 13 days ago | 🔍 |
|
| 83rd | Djchief | 310 | 45 | 355 | 1 month ago | 🔍 |
|
| 84th | Sparrowsjack | 309 | 230 | 539 | 2 months ago | 🔍 |
|
| 85th | Rompinrabbit | 309 | 104 | 413 | 1 month ago | 🔍 |
|
| 86th | Kunoruk | 308 | 339 | 647 | 2 months ago | 🔍 |
|
| 87th | Alpha | 308 | 248 | 556 | 2 months ago | 🔍 |
|
| 88th | Wolo | 308 | 66 | 374 | 28 days ago | 🔍 |
|
| 89th | Hacko | 307 | 178 | 485 | 12 days ago | 🔍 |
|
| 90th | Ryuken | 307 | 96 | 403 | 1 month ago | 🔍 |
|
| 91st | Mastere | 307 | 90 | 397 | 2 months ago | 🔍 |
|
| 92nd | Shiri | 306 | 270 | 576 | 2 months ago | 🔍 |
|
| 93rd | Jfmaa | 306 | 243 | 549 | 1 month ago | 🔍 |
|
| 94th | Tilinka | 305 | 266 | 571 | 2 months ago | 🔍 |
|
| 95th | Blackteach | 304 | 328 | 632 | 2 months ago | 🔍 |
|
| 96th | Lucicafer | 304 | 144 | 448 | 2 months ago | 🔍 |
|
| 97th | Skipperboi | 304 | 100 | 404 | 1 month ago | 🔍 |
|
| 98th | Liyum | 302 | 140 | 442 | 2 months ago | 🔍 |
|
| 99th | Qul | 302 | 87 | 389 | 20 days ago | 🔍 |
|
| 100th | Millet | 301 | 73 | 374 | 1 month ago | 🔍 |
|
| 1st | Diletto | 432 | 279 | 711 | 18 days ago | 🔍 |
|
| 2nd | Fourteen | 399 | 475 | 874 | 15 days ago | 🔍 |
|
| 3rd | Crip | 388 | 348 | 736 | 30 days ago | 🔍 |
|
| 4th | Sherbetlemon | 378 | 484 | 862 | 1 month ago | 🔍 |
|
| 5th | Metaalmeisje | 374 | 327 | 701 | 1 month ago | 🔍 |
|
| 6th | Zingman | 364 | 500 | 864 | 1 month ago | 🔍 |
|
| 7th | Fooqueso | 359 | 222 | 581 | 18 days ago | 🔍 |
|
| 8th | Emiya | 357 | 301 | 658 | 30 days ago | 🔍 |
|
| 9th | Cpntook | 356 | 368 | 724 | 1 month ago | 🔍 |
|
| 10th | Bealotus | 346 | 480 | 826 | 18 days ago | 🔍 |
|
| 11th | Orchidee | 343 | 492 | 835 | 1 month ago | 🔍 |
|
| 12th | Crabbycrank | 339 | 502 | 841 | 1 month ago | 🔍 |
|
| 13th | Ttoonnyy | 337 | 424 | 761 | 1 month ago | 🔍 |
|
| 14th | Kriscri | 335 | 485 | 820 | 1 month ago | 🔍 |
|
| 15th | Garibaldi | 334 | 445 | 779 | 1 month ago | 🔍 |
|
| 16th | Auraluna | 333 | 270 | 603 | 1 month ago | 🔍 |
|
| 17th | Starsailors | 329 | 442 | 771 | 1 month ago | 🔍 |
|
| 18th | Zelnok | 327 | 196 | 523 | 1 month ago | 🔍 |
|
| 19th | Eveiemarie | 325 | 380 | 705 | 1 month ago | 🔍 |
|
| 20th | Ryujin | 319 | 253 | 572 | 1 month ago | 🔍 |
|
| 21st | Gunnerfreak | 315 | 228 | 543 | 1 month ago | 🔍 |
|
| 22nd | Hardcastle | 313 | 192 | 505 | 1 month ago | 🔍 |
|
| 23rd | Xelliana | 312 | 137 | 449 | 1 month ago | 🔍 |
|
| 24th | Babydolls | 311 | 333 | 644 | 1 month ago | 🔍 |
|
| 25th | Aset | 311 | 226 | 537 | 1 month ago | 🔍 |
|
| 26th | Vampyone | 308 | 253 | 561 | 1 month ago | 🔍 |
|
| 27th | Polestar | 308 | 180 | 488 | 1 month ago | 🔍 |
|
| 28th | Katez | 308 | 180 | 488 | 1 month ago | 🔍 |
|
| 29th | Armegin | 304 | 110 | 414 | 13 days ago | 🔍 |
|
| 30th | Mommawolf | 301 | 482 | 783 | 1 month ago | 🔍 |
|
| 31st | Allitara | 301 | 284 | 585 | 1 month ago | 🔍 |
|
| 32nd | Piratemagic | 293 | 286 | 579 | 2 months ago | 🔍 |
|
| 33rd | Jennafrog | 291 | 323 | 614 | 1 month ago | 🔍 |
|
| 34th | Annarinda | 287 | 153 | 440 | 1 month ago | 🔍 |
|
| 35th | Majorjr | 286 | 244 | 530 | 1 month ago | 🔍 |
|
| 36th | Zurf | 284 | 376 | 660 | 19 days ago | 🔍 |
|
| 37th | Evilchris | 283 | 260 | 543 | 1 month ago | 🔍 |
|
| 38th | Darkseid | 282 | 144 | 426 | 1 month ago | 🔍 |
|
| 39th | Palefire | 281 | 224 | 505 | 1 month ago | 🔍 |
|
| 40th | Smythedon | 279 | 235 | 514 | 1 month ago | 🔍 |
|
| 41st | Snort | 279 | 174 | 453 | 1 month ago | 🔍 |
|
| 42nd | Haunter | 278 | 363 | 641 | 9 days ago | 🔍 |
|
| 43rd | Marebare | 276 | 88 | 364 | 1 month ago | 🔍 |
|
| 44th | Madanne | 272 | 432 | 704 | 1 month ago | 🔍 |
|
| 45th | Freja | 272 | 412 | 684 | 1 month ago | 🔍 |
|
| 46th | Rhodanite | 271 | 247 | 518 | 1 month ago | 🔍 |
|
| 47th | Irishanam | 271 | 125 | 396 | 1 month ago | 🔍 |
|
| 48th | Kymberlee | 270 | 368 | 638 | 1 month ago | 🔍 |
|
| 49th | Donsmythe | 270 | 278 | 548 | 1 month ago | 🔍 |
|
| 50th | Boonsteer | 269 | 284 | 553 | 1 month ago | 🔍 |
|
| 51st | Fathomfive | 268 | 196 | 464 | 1 month ago | 🔍 |
|
| 52nd | Dexavis | 267 | 89 | 356 | 1 month ago | 🔍 |
|
| 53rd | Hizzo | 266 | 121 | 387 | 1 month ago | 🔍 |
|
| 54th | Lanlaiely | 265 | 224 | 489 | 1 month ago | 🔍 |
|
| 55th | Darlie | 263 | 100 | 363 | 1 month ago | 🔍 |
|
| 56th | Wheelie | 262 | 188 | 450 | 1 month ago | 🔍 |
|
| 57th | Majestrate | 262 | 151 | 413 | 1 month ago | 🔍 |
|
| 58th | Zadkiel | 262 | 113 | 375 | 1 month ago | 🔍 |
|
| 59th | Booman | 262 | 79 | 341 | 1 month ago | 🔍 |
|
| 60th | Vova | 261 | 119 | 380 | 1 month ago | 🔍 |
|
| 61st | Fourking | 260 | 260 | 520 | 1 month ago | 🔍 |
|
| 62nd | Semp | 260 | 175 | 435 | 1 month ago | 🔍 |
|
| 63rd | Tammstar | 260 | 122 | 382 | 1 month ago | 🔍 |
|
| 64th | Tillathehuny | 258 | 148 | 406 | 1 month ago | 🔍 |
|
| 65th | Nickbush | 256 | 104 | 360 | 1 month ago | 🔍 |
|
| 66th | Rascalslove | 253 | 203 | 456 | 1 month ago | 🔍 |
|
| 67th | Randumb | 250 | 161 | 411 | 1 month ago | 🔍 |
|
| 68th | Cheshi | 250 | 136 | 386 | 1 month ago | 🔍 |
|
| 69th | Boohey | 249 | 160 | 409 | 1 month ago | 🔍 |
|
| 70th | Emerlaus | 249 | 106 | 355 | 1 month ago | 🔍 |
|
| 71st | Vansalee | 247 | 263 | 510 | 1 month ago | 🔍 |
|
| 72nd | Cptnronen | 246 | 180 | 426 | 1 month ago | 🔍 |
|
| 73rd | Blackleather | 243 | 306 | 549 | 1 month ago | 🔍 |
|
| 74th | Samjones | 243 | 257 | 500 | 1 month ago | 🔍 |
|
| 75th | Rome | 242 | 242 | 484 | 1 month ago | 🔍 |
|
| 76th | Scap | 241 | 113 | 354 | 1 month ago | 🔍 |
|
| 77th | Onelovefun | 241 | 99 | 340 | 1 month ago | 🔍 |
|
| 78th | Howee | 240 | 265 | 505 | 1 month ago | 🔍 |
|
| 79th | Zarchi | 240 | 82 | 322 | 1 month ago | 🔍 |
|
| 80th | Cem | 238 | 107 | 345 | 1 month ago | 🔍 |
|
| 81st | Topgunn | 238 | 97 | 335 | 1 month ago | 🔍 |
|
| 82nd | Jackseagull | 236 | 243 | 479 | 1 month ago | 🔍 |
|
| 83rd | Trol | 235 | 159 | 394 | 1 month ago | 🔍 |
|
| 84th | Aurely | 233 | 132 | 365 | 1 month ago | 🔍 |
|
| 85th | Tzz | 232 | 73 | 305 | 1 month ago | 🔍 |
|
| 86th | Zaiita | 231 | 91 | 322 | 1 month ago | 🔍 |
|
| 87th | Voidrix | 230 | 78 | 308 | 1 month ago | 🔍 |
|
| 88th | Fomo | 228 | 103 | 331 | 22 days ago | 🔍 |
|
| 89th | Harrjm | 227 | 127 | 354 | 1 month ago | 🔍 |
|
| 90th | Orrorin | 225 | 341 | 566 | 1 month ago | 🔍 |
|
| 91st | Karakiz | 225 | 276 | 501 | 1 month ago | 🔍 |
|
| 92nd | Fedorov | 225 | 172 | 397 | 1 month ago | 🔍 |
|
| 93rd | Aeowyn | 225 | 169 | 394 | 1 month ago | 🔍 |
|
| 94th | Breenyc | 223 | 159 | 382 | 1 month ago | 🔍 |
|
| 95th | Iokaste | 222 | 200 | 422 | 1 month ago | 🔍 |
|
| 96th | Jsweetie | 222 | 93 | 315 | 1 month ago | 🔍 |
|
| 97th | Jacqie | 221 | 160 | 381 | 2 days ago | 🔍 |
|
| 98th | Mousebeard | 219 | 90 | 309 | 1 month ago | 🔍 |
|
| 99th | Tdoggy | 218 | 118 | 336 | 1 month ago | 🔍 |
|
| 100th | Madmaddiemae | 218 | 84 | 302 | 1 month ago | 🔍 |
|
| 1st | Scottys | 470 | 206 | 676 | 16 hours ago | 🔍 |
|
| 2nd | Iuffy | 442 | 280 | 722 | 5 days ago | 🔍 |
|
| 3rd | Ilkko | 378 | 248 | 626 | 1 day ago | 🔍 |
|
| 4th | Westly | 343 | 182 | 525 | 8 months ago | 🔍 |
|
| 5th | Esaidra | 336 | 359 | 695 | 4 months ago | 🔍 |
|
| 6th | Gagundss | 333 | 210 | 543 | 5 months ago | 🔍 |
|
| 7th | Nathaliee | 329 | 138 | 467 | 1 day ago | 🔍 |
|
| 8th | Owlwhisperer | 328 | 455 | 783 | 1 month ago | 🔍 |
|
| 9th | Twoknives | 325 | 338 | 663 | 18 days ago | 🔍 |
|
| 10th | Solame | 324 | 200 | 524 | 5 months ago | 🔍 |
|
| 11th | Irig | 321 | 182 | 503 | 1 month ago | 🔍 |
|
| 12th | Gunray | 317 | 322 | 639 | 4 months ago | 🔍 |
|
| 13th | Unca | 314 | 167 | 481 | 5 months ago | 🔍 |
|
| 14th | Missdeliah | 308 | 121 | 429 | 5 months ago | 🔍 |
|
| 15th | Mccoo | 305 | 179 | 484 | 6 months ago | 🔍 |
|
| 16th | Cencul | 301 | 196 | 497 | 2 months ago | 🔍 |
|
| 17th | Monlizzy | 299 | 232 | 531 | 8 months ago | 🔍 |
|
| 18th | Budclare | 293 | 213 | 506 | 7 months ago | 🔍 |
|
| 19th | Cheesecakey | 285 | 325 | 610 | 5 months ago | 🔍 |
|
| 20th | Pappy | 285 | 235 | 520 | 6 months ago | 🔍 |
|
| 21st | Technologic | 282 | 139 | 421 | 2 months ago | 🔍 |
|
| 22nd | Yumisa | 281 | 107 | 388 | 1 year ago | 🔍 |
|
| 23rd | Wasabia | 276 | 164 | 440 | 5 months ago | 🔍 |
|
| 24th | Maccy | 276 | 84 | 360 | 1 year ago | 🔍 |
|
| 25th | Auntyjinxed | 273 | 180 | 453 | 6 months ago | 🔍 |
|
| 26th | Pilara | 271 | 129 | 400 | 6 months ago | 🔍 |
|
| 27th | Kelvinchi | 269 | 135 | 404 | 1 year ago | 🔍 |
|
| 28th | Ikke | 267 | 92 | 359 | 1 year ago | 🔍 |
|
| 29th | Gnster | 267 | 60 | 327 | 8 months ago | 🔍 |
|
| 30th | Niematorie | 266 | 161 | 427 | 4 days ago | 🔍 |
|
| 31st | Grumbles | 265 | 223 | 488 | 1 year ago | 🔍 |
|
| 32nd | Sokol | 265 | 97 | 362 | 8 months ago | 🔍 |
|
| 33rd | Strategery | 262 | 331 | 593 | 10 months ago | 🔍 |
|
| 34th | Mej | 260 | 383 | 643 | 5 months ago | 🔍 |
|
| 35th | Mcgillicutti | 260 | 207 | 467 | 7 months ago | 🔍 |
|
| 36th | Staycr | 258 | 115 | 373 | 6 months ago | 🔍 |
|
| 37th | Gonkeightleg | 255 | 109 | 364 | 6 months ago | 🔍 |
|
| 38th | Gailchips | 253 | 147 | 400 | 18 days ago | 🔍 |
|
| 39th | Buzzybear | 250 | 79 | 329 | 5 months ago | 🔍 |
|
| 40th | Taytaytatty | 245 | 58 | 303 | 7 months ago | 🔍 |
|
| 41st | Rougaroux | 243 | 173 | 416 | 5 months ago | 🔍 |
|
| 42nd | Brisky | 240 | 83 | 323 | 1 month ago | 🔍 |
|
| 43rd | Knightofni | 238 | 66 | 304 | 5 months ago | 🔍 |
|
| 44th | Olize | 238 | 46 | 284 | 4 months ago | 🔍 |
|
| 45th | Imamy | 236 | 110 | 346 | 5 months ago | 🔍 |
|
| 46th | Accom | 236 | 49 | 285 | 4 months ago | 🔍 |
|
| 47th | Tarsius | 235 | 154 | 389 | 1 year ago | 🔍 |
|
| 48th | Yote | 233 | 194 | 427 | 9 months ago | 🔍 |
|
| 49th | Hydroactive | 232 | 46 | 278 | 1 year ago | 🔍 |
|
| 50th | Breezeblock | 232 | 35 | 267 | 1 day ago | 🔍 |
|
| 51st | Jaymonkey | 231 | 67 | 298 | 1 year ago | 🔍 |
|
| 52nd | Mamabuns | 229 | 104 | 333 | 5 months ago | 🔍 |
|
| 53rd | Dyrbar | 229 | 96 | 325 | 7 months ago | 🔍 |
|
| 54th | Pisballpete | 227 | 369 | 596 | 5 months ago | 🔍 |
|
| 55th | Ninjaturtle | 225 | 59 | 284 | 10 months ago | 🔍 |
|
| 56th | Moyi | 224 | 83 | 307 | 1 month ago | 🔍 |
|
| 57th | Alexxander | 223 | 55 | 278 | 1 year ago | 🔍 |
|
| 58th | Mayne | 220 | 26 | 246 | 9 months ago | 🔍 |
|
| 59th | Rajoejoe | 218 | 85 | 303 | 1 year ago | 🔍 |
|
| 60th | Adrielle | 216 | 124 | 340 | 22 days ago | 🔍 |
|
| 61st | Qwertibob | 216 | 117 | 333 | 7 months ago | 🔍 |
|
| 62nd | Shadymermady | 216 | 106 | 322 | 1 month ago | 🔍 |
|
| 63rd | Saltpetre | 216 | 92 | 308 | 4 months ago | 🔍 |
|
| 64th | Ngatitutu | 215 | 149 | 364 | 18 days ago | 🔍 |
|
| 65th | Flooraa | 212 | 105 | 317 | 5 months ago | 🔍 |
|
| 66th | Technitium | 212 | 78 | 290 | 9 months ago | 🔍 |
|
| 67th | Ever | 212 | 67 | 279 | 4 months ago | 🔍 |
|
| 68th | Krueger | 211 | 52 | 263 | 9 months ago | 🔍 |
|
| 69th | Ennazus | 210 | 116 | 326 | 8 months ago | 🔍 |
|
| 70th | Penguinbr | 210 | 77 | 287 | 1 year ago | 🔍 |
|
| 71st | Wayfarer | 209 | 79 | 288 | 5 months ago | 🔍 |
|
| 72nd | Mastercarlos | 209 | 72 | 281 | 4 months ago | 🔍 |
|
| 73rd | Ganderz | 209 | 60 | 269 | 1 year ago | 🔍 |
|
| 74th | Dragontooth | 208 | 184 | 392 | 4 months ago | 🔍 |
|
| 75th | Luckyliza | 208 | 127 | 335 | 1 year ago | 🔍 |
|
| 76th | Kerostar | 207 | 40 | 247 | 7 months ago | 🔍 |
|
| 77th | Septembersun | 206 | 88 | 294 | 1 year ago | 🔍 |
|
| 78th | Fable | 206 | 82 | 288 | 4 months ago | 🔍 |
|
| 79th | Johnpickle | 205 | 68 | 273 | 1 year ago | 🔍 |
|
| 80th | Niobetha | 204 | 99 | 303 | 9 months ago | 🔍 |
|
| 81st | Rossignol | 203 | 112 | 315 | 7 months ago | 🔍 |
|
| 82nd | Superluki | 202 | 67 | 269 | 5 months ago | 🔍 |
|
| 83rd | Flar | 201 | 69 | 270 | 4 months ago | 🔍 |
|
| 84th | Flamewing | 199 | 90 | 289 | 4 months ago | 🔍 |
|
| 85th | Jackeroe | 198 | 134 | 332 | 9 months ago | 🔍 |
|
| 86th | Skippy | 198 | 116 | 314 | 10 months ago | 🔍 |
|
| 87th | Hateme | 193 | 65 | 258 | 6 months ago | 🔍 |
|
| 88th | Camouflages | 191 | 55 | 246 | 11 months ago | 🔍 |
|
| 89th | Timewreaker | 189 | 33 | 222 | 1 year ago | 🔍 |
|
| 90th | Thecrook | 188 | 109 | 297 | 6 months ago | 🔍 |
|
| 91st | Tzz | 188 | 45 | 233 | 6 months ago | 🔍 |
|
| 92nd | Heffalumpy | 188 | 39 | 227 | 9 months ago | 🔍 |
|
| 93rd | Krull | 186 | 82 | 268 | 1 year ago | 🔍 |
|
| 94th | Coasty | 186 | 66 | 252 | 5 months ago | 🔍 |
|
| 95th | Peperox | 185 | 73 | 258 | 1 year ago | 🔍 |
|
| 96th | Geologist | 184 | 57 | 241 | 1 year ago | 🔍 |
|
| 97th | Strategy | 184 | 44 | 228 | 1 year ago | 🔍 |
|
| 98th | Katyb | 183 | 122 | 305 | 6 months ago | 🔍 |
|
| 99th | Ichigokuro | 182 | 297 | 479 | 9 months ago | 🔍 |
|
| 100th | Ions | 181 | 72 | 253 | 7 months ago | 🔍 |
|
| Not yet categorized on YPPedia when last checked |
|---|
 Battered Hat - Awarded to pirates who perform sailing, rigging, carpentry, patching, and bilging for at least 15 minutes on four of the duty stations and at least 10 minutes on the fifth duty station in a blockade. The puzzling can be done in one or more rounds of the same blockade. The ship must be on the board and able to influence blockade buoys. |  Weathered Helm - Awarded to pirates at the helm of a ship for 50% of a blockade round, whether on the sea battle board or doing other duties while at the helm. The ship must be on the board and able to influence blockade buoys. |
 Flag Bearer - 100 buoys influenced |  Color Guard - 500 buoys influenced |  Old Glory - 1,000 buoys influenced |  Victory Banner - 5,000 buoys influenced |
 Iron Coils - Excellent Rigging |  Iron Hammer - Excellent Carpentry |  Iron Pump - Excellent Bilging |  Iron Tackle - Excellent Sailing |
 Steel Coils - Incredible Rigging |  Steel Hammer - Incredible Carpentry |  Steel Pump - Incredible Bilging |  Steel Tackle - Incredible Sailing |
| Fine/Good | Excellent | Incredible |
|---|---|---|
 Oaken Token of Bilge - 100 tokens earned |  Seal of Bilge - 100 tokens earned |  Pillars of Bilge - 100 tokens earned |
 Token of Water - 5,000 tokens earned |  Water Marble - 5,000 tokens earned |  Towers of Water - 5,000 tokens earned |
 Token of the Pump - 17,250 tokens earned |  Seal of the Pump - 17,250 tokens earned |  Spires of the Pump - 17,250 tokens earned |
| Fine/Good | Excellent | Incredible |
|---|---|---|
 Oaken Token of Carpentry - 100 tokens earned |  Seal of Carpentry - 100 tokens earned |  Pillars of Carpentry - 100 tokens earned |
 Token of Wood - 5,000 tokens earned |  Wooden Stair - 5,000 tokens earned |  Towers of Wood - 5,000 tokens earned |
 Token of the Hammer - 17,250 tokens earned |  Seal of the Hammer - 17,250 tokens earned |  Spires of the Hammer - 17,250 tokens earned |
| Fine/Good | Excellent | Incredible |
|---|---|---|
 Oaken Token of Patching - 100 tokens earned |  Seal of Patching - 100 tokens earned |  Pillars of Patching - 100 tokens earned |
 Token of Thread - 5,000 tokens earned |  Thread Ball - 5,000 tokens earned |  Towers of Thread - 5,000 tokens earned |
 Token of the Spool - 17,250 tokens earned |  Seal of the Spool - 17,250 tokens earned |  Spires of the Spool - 17,250 tokens earned |
| Fine/Good | Excellent | Incredible |
|---|---|---|
 Oaken Token of Rigging - 100 tokens earned |  Seal of Rigging - 100 tokens earned |  Pillars of Rigging - 100 tokens earned |
 Token of Rope - 5,000 tokens earned |  Rope Knot - 5,000 tokens earned |  Towers of Rope - 5,000 tokens earned |
 Token of the Sheets - 17,250 tokens earned |  Seal of the Sheets - 17,250 tokens earned |  Spires of the Sheets - 17,250 tokens earned |
| Fine/Good | Excellent | Incredible |
|---|---|---|
 Oaken Token of Sails - 100 tokens earned |  Seal of Sails - 100 tokens earned |  Pillars of Sails - 100 tokens earned |
 Token of Wind - 5,000 tokens earned |  Wind Marble - 5,000 tokens earned |  Towers of Wind - 5,000 tokens earned |
 Token of the Tackle - 17,250 tokens earned |  Seal of the Tackle - 17,250 tokens earned |  Spires of the Tackle - 17,250 tokens earned |
| Ships sunk, both reds and greens. |  Flotilla Freebooter - 5 ships sunk |  Flotilla Fighter - 25 ships sunk |  Flotilla Fanatic - 100 ships sunk |
|---|
| 5 sinks | 25 sinks | 100 sinks | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Cutter |  Cutter Hunter - |  Cutter Slayer - |  Cutter Bane - |
| Merchant brig |  Merchant Brig Hunter - |  Merchant Brig Slayer - |  Merchant Brig Bane - |
| Merchant galleon |  Merchant Galleon Hunter - |  Merchant Galleon Slayer - |  Merchant Galleon Bane - |
| Skellie frays |  Skellie Hunter - First fray won |  Skellie Slayer - 10 frays won |  Skellies' Bane - 100 frays won |
|---|---|---|---|
| Werewolf frays |  Werewolf Hunter - First fray won |  Werewolf Slayer - 10 frays won |  Werewolf's Bane - 100 frays won |
| Zombie frays |  Zombie Hunter - First fray won |  Zombie Slayer - 10 frays won |  Zombies' Bane - 100 frays won |
| Vampirate frays |  Vampirate Hunter - First fray won |  Vampirate Slayer - 10 frays won |  Vampirate's Bane - 100 frays won |
| Ghost frays |  Ghost Hunter - First fray won |  Ghost Slayer - 10 frays won |  Ghost's Bane - 100 frays won |
| Skulls |  Bone Head - First skull won |  Head Hunter - 10 skulls won |  Head Honcho - 100 skulls won |
| Tufts of fur |  Tufted Wolf-Wear - First tuft of fur won |  Shiny Shapeshifter - 10 tufts of fur won |  Gilded Loup Garou - 100 tufts of fur won |
|---|---|---|---|
| Zombie hands |  Fresh Zombie Hand - First zombie hand won |  Preserved Zombie Hand - 10 zombie hands won |  Bronzed Zombie Hand - 100 zombie hands won |
| Vampirate Fangs |  Fang Finagler - First vampirate fang won |  Fangy Pack - 10 vampirate fangs won |  Fangtastic! - 100 vampirate fangs won |
| Ecto-blobs |  Bandana Full o' Spirit Slime - First Ecto-blob won |  Boots Full o' Spirit Slime - 10 Ecto-blobs won |  Boat Full o' Spirit Slime - 100 Ecto-blobs won |
 Deck Hand - 15 league points traveled |  Seafarer - 30 league points traveled |  Mariner - 500 league points traveled |
| 10 wins | 50 wins | 250 wins | 1,250 wins | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Sloop |  Bronze Sloop - |  Silver Sloop - |  Gold Sloop - |  Diamond Sloop - |
| Cutter |  Bronze Cutter - |  Silver Cutter - |  Gold Cutter - |  Diamond Cutter - |
| Dhow |  Bronze Dhow - |  Silver Dhow - |  Gold Dhow - |  Diamond Dhow - |
| Fanchuan |  Bronze Fanchuan - |  Silver Fanchuan - |  Gold Fanchuan - |  Diamond Fanchuan - |
| Longship |  Bronze Longship - |  Silver Longship - |  Gold Longship - |  Diamond Longship - |
| Baghlah |  Bronze Baghlah - |  Silver Baghlah - |  Gold Baghlah - |  Diamond Baghlah - |
| Merchant Brig |  Bronze Merchant Brig - |  Silver Merchant Brig - |  Gold Merchant Brig - |  Diamond Merchant Brig - |
| Junk |  Bronze Junk - |  Silver Junk - |  Gold Junk - |  Diamond Junk - |
| War Brig |  Bronze War Brig - |  Silver War Brig - |  Gold War Brig - |  Diamond War Brig - |
| Merchant Galleon |  Bronze Merchant Galleon - |  Silver Merchant Galleon - |  Gold Merchant Galleon - |  Diamond Merchant Galleon - |
| Xebec |  Bronze Xebec - |  Silver Xebec - |  Gold Xebec - |  Diamond Xebec - |
| War Frigate |  Bronze War Frigate - |  Silver War Frigate - |  Gold War Frigate - |  Diamond War Frigate - |
| Grand Frigate |  Bronze Grand Frigate - |  Silver Grand Frigate - |  Gold Grand Frigate - |  Diamond Grand Frigate - |
| Buried treasure expeditions |  Beach Comber - First expedition completed |  Sandbar Skipper - 10 expeditions completed |  Reef Raider - 50 expeditions completed |  Island Hopper - 200 expeditions completed |
|---|---|---|---|---|
 Bronze Spoon - 500 kilograms of chests foraged |  Silver Pickaxe - 5,000 kilograms of chests foraged |  Golden Spade - 50,000 kilograms of chests foraged | ||
 Oyster - Clicking on the tombstone of the Old Man from Oyster Island during an expedition | ||||
| Merchant hunt expeditions |  Pilfered Goods - First win |  Hijacked Load - 10 wins |  Swiped Cargo - 50 wins |  Plundered Loot - 200 wins |
| Shipwreck expeditions |  Waterlogged Spyglass - First expedition completed |  Sunken Ship's Bell - 10 expeditions completed |  Cannon of the Deep - 50 expeditions completed |  Lost Figurehead - 200 expeditions completed |
| Yeti Sighting expeditions1 |  Hasty Sketch - First expedition completed |  Detailed Rendering - 10 expeditions completed |  Scale Model - 30 expeditions completed | No trophy known |
| Imperial outposts |  Imperial Private Insignia - First successful attack |  Imperial Corporal Insignia - 10 successful attacks |  Imperial Captain Insignia - 50 successful attacks |  Imperial Colonel Insignia - 200 successful attacks |
 Stomped Shako - First successful sinking attack |  Tattered Flag - 10 successful sinking attacks |  Battered Shield - 50 successful sinking attacks |  Toppled Crown - 200 successful sinking attacks | |
| Viking expeditions |  Splintered Axes - First successful defense |  Shattered Swords - 10 successful defenses |  Crumpled Helm - 50 successful defenses |  Bashed Shield - 200 successful defenses |
 Longship Vanquisher - Deal max damage to a longship while on a Viking expedition | ||||
| Vampirate expeditions |  Bronze Bloodsucker - First sea battle against vampirates won |  Silver Strigoi - 25 sea battles against vampirates won |  Golden Gloom-walker - 100 sea battles against vampirates won |  Diamond Dark-flier - 200 sea battles against vampirates won |
 Blood Box - Unknown |  Chiropteran Cask - Unknown |  Sanguinary Seachest - Unknown | ||
 Coffin Carpenter - Scoring a Frenetic at carpenting |  Heroic Hauler - Scoring a Frenetic at treasure hauling | |||
 Simple Sanctum - Unknown |  Bronze Bastion - Unknown |  Golden Gore-hall - Unknown |  Silver Stronghold - Unknown | |
 Mother's Bonnet - First winning fray against the Mother o' Nyght | ||||
| Werewolf expeditions |  Berzerk Bronze Badge - First sea battle against werewolves won |  Savage Silver Signet - 25 sea battles against werewolves won |  Animalistic Auric Arms - 100 sea battles against werewolves won |  Direwolf's Diamond Device - 200 sea battles against werewolves won |
 Beast Box - Unknown |  Lupine Locker - Unknown |  Chest o' the Wildwood - Unknown |
| Brigand King | First win | 10 wins | 25 wins |
|---|---|---|---|
| Admiral Finius |  Bronze Finius Pennant - |  Silver Finius Pennant - |  Gold Finius Pennant - |
| Azarbad the Great |  Bronze Eye of Flame - |  Silver Eye of Flame - |  Gold Eye of Flame - |
| Barnabas the Pale |  Bronze Death's Head - |  Silver Death's Head - |  Gold Death's Head - |
| Brynhild Skullsplitter |  Bronze Valkyrie Helm - |  Silver Valkyrie Helm - |  Gold Valkyrie Helm - |
| Gretchen Goldfang |  Bronze Jaws - |  Silver Jaws - |  Gold Jaws - |
| Madam Yu Jian |  Bronze Sigil - |  Silver Sigil - |  Gold Sigil - |
| Vargas the Mad |  Bronze Seal of Madness - |  Silver Seal of Madness - |  Gold Seal of Madness - |
| The Widow Queen |  Bronze Hourglass - |  Silver Hourglass - |  Gold Hourglass - |
| Stealing Lavish Lockers1 |  Greedy Handful - 5 Lavish Lockers stolen |  Greedy Pile - 50 Lavish Lockers stolen |  Greedy Heap - 300 Lavish Lockers stolen |  Greedy Trove - 1,000 Lavish Lockers stolen |  Greedy Hoard - 3,000 Lavish Lockers stolen |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Delivering strikes to greedy brigands2 |  Greedy Poker - 5 swordfight strikes delivered |  Greedy Lunger - 50 swordfight strikes delivered |  Greedy Striker - 250 swordfight attacks delivered |  Greedy Barrager - 500 swordfight attacks delivered |  Greedy Sword Stormer - 1,000 swordfight attacks delivered |
| Executing attacks to greedy barbarians2 |  Emerald Blackjack - 5 rumble attacks executed |  Ruby Gaff - 50 rumble attacks executed |  Sapphire Brass Knuckles - 250 rumble attacks executed |  Amethyst Chain n' Pin - 500 rumble attacks executed |  Black Diamond Rumbler - 1,000 rumble attacks executed |
| Knocking out greedy bots3 |  Gold Cloth Scrap - 5 greedy bots eliminated |  Gold Tooth - 50 greedy bots eliminated |  Gold Tooth n' Patch - 300 greedy bots eliminated |  Hijacked Jewelry - 1,000 greedy bots eliminated |  Finders Keepers Losers Weepers - 3,000 greedy bots eliminated |
 Inner Skelly - Use a skeletal amulet to transform into a skellie. | |||
 Skeleton Crew - Win a sea battle alongside a skeleton |  Bone Brothers - Win sea battles alongside 25 skeletons. |  Corpse Corps - Win sea battles alongside 250 skeletons. |  Army of Darkness - Win sea battles alongside 1,000 skeletons. |
| Winning kraken's blood |  Mug o' Blood - First kraken's blood won |  Chalice of Blood - 10 kraken's blood won |  Bowl of Blood - 100 kraken's blood won |
| Defeating a monkey boat |  Brotherhood of the Bronze Pineapple - First monkey boat defeated |  Society of the Silver Coconut - 10 monkey boats defeated |  Order of the Golden Banana - 100 monkey boats defeated |
 Hair of the Dog - 25 rumless sea battles which result in a swordfight or rumble. |
 Driftwood - First sink |  Soggy Boot - 100 sinks |
| First journey | First sink | |
| Atlantis |  Atlantean Explorer - |  Atlantean Tablet - |
| Cursed Isles |  Cursed Banner - Must reach the island. |  Briny Mask - |
| Haunted Seas |  Pale Runner - |  Ghost Fish - |
| Kraken |  Coat of Arms - | No trophy |
 Soggy Chest - 50 chests hauled |  Valuable Chest - 250 chests hauled |  Glittering Chest - 1,250 chests hauled |  Overflowing Chest - 6,250 chests hauled |
| 5 sinks | 200 sinks | 1,000 sinks | |
| Triketos |  Bronze Triketos - |  Silver Triketos - |  Golden Triketos - |
| Gorgonyx |  Bronze Gorgonyx - |  Silver Gorgonyx - |  Golden Gorgonyx - |
| Archelon |  Bronze Archelon - |  Silver Archelon - |  Golden Archelon - |
 Bronze Citadel - First citadel won |  Silver Citadel - 25 citadels won |  Golden Citadel - 100 citadel won |
 Bellator's Bane - 5 winning swordfights. |
 Cursed Forager - 500 kilograms of chests foraged |  Hexed Forager - 5,000 kilograms of chests foraged |  Enlightened Forager - 50,000 kilograms of chests foraged |
 Frenetic Forager - Scoring a Frenetic at foraging |
 Cultist Crusher - 5 frays won |  Enlightened Eradicator - 50 frays won |  Homunculus Humbler - 500 frays won |
 Vargas Vanquisher - First winning fray against Vargas the Mad |
 Haunted Chest - 50 chests hauled |  Eerie Chest - 250 chests hauled |  Chilling Chest - 1,250 chests hauled |  Unearthly Chest - 6,250 chests hauled |
| 5 sinks | 200 sinks | 1,000 sinks | |
| Ghost Sloop |  Bronze Ghost Sloop - |  Silver Ghost Sloop - |  Golden Ghost Sloop - |
| Ghost Brig |  Bronze Ghost Brig - |  Silver Ghost Brig - |  Golden Ghost Brig - |
| Ghost Frigate |  Bronze Ghost Frigate - |  Silver Ghost Frigate - |  Golden Ghost Frigate - |
 Bronze Ship Graveyard - First graveyard won |  Silver Ship Graveyard - 50 graveyards won |  Golden Ship Graveyard - 500 graveyards won |
 Hoard Burglar - 50 chests/eggs loaded |  Hoard Thief - 200 chests/eggs loaded |  Hoard Raider - 1000 chests/eggs loaded |  Hoard Bandit - 2500 chests/eggs loaded |
 One-eyed Jack - 1 dozen (12) eggs loaded |  Flailing Flan - 4 dozen (48) eggs loaded |  Deviled Eggs - 12 dozen (144) eggs loaded |  Hard Boiled - 30 dozen (360) eggs loaded |
 Ink splotch - 50 inks loaded |  Rorschach - 250 inks loaded |  Seal of Ink - Unknown number of inks loaded |
 Kraken Skulls - 20 Kraken Heads bombed |  Krak Head - 200 Kraken Heads bombed |  Boom! Headshot - 800 Kraken Heads bombed |
 Sea Legs - Completing 5 missions. |
 Barfly - Drinking |  Fencer - Swordfight |  Scrapper - Rumble |
| Patron | Explorer | Conqueror | Magnate | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Celebrated |  Bronzed Tourney Board - |  Bronze-bound Atlas - |  Bronze Gauntlet - |  Stamped Ingot - |
| Eminent |  Sterling Tourney Board - |  Silver Embossed Atlas - |  Silver Gauntlet - |  Initialed Ingot - |
| Illustrious |  Bejeweled Tourney Board - |  Gilded Atlas - |  Golden Gauntlet - |  Monogrammed Ingot - |
 Ultimate Pirate - All ultimate piracy trophies |  Ultimate Carouser - All ultimate carousing trophies |  Ultimate Crafter - All ultimate crafting trophies |
 Ultimate of Ultimates - Ultimate Pirate, Ultimate Carouser, and Ultimate Crafter. |
| Ultimate | #1 | Broad | Expert | Sublime | Revered | Exalted | Transcendent | Incredible | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Battle Navigator |  - |  - |  - |  - |  - |  - |  - |  - | No trophy |
| Bilger |  - |  - |  - |  - |  - |  - |  - |  - |  - |
| Carpenter |  - |  - |  - |  - |  - |  - |  - |  - |  - |
| Gunner |  - |  - |  - |  - |  - |  - |  - |  - |  - |
| Navigator |  - |  - |  - |  - |  - |  - |  - |  - |  - |
| Patcher |  - |  - |  - |  - |  - |  - |  - |  - |  - |
| Rigger |  - |  - |  - |  - |  - |  - |  - |  - |  - |
| Rumbler |  - |  - |  - |  - |  - |  - |  - |  - | No trophy |
| Sailor |  - |  - |  - |  - |  - |  - |  - |  - |  - |
| Swordfighter |  - |  - |  - |  - |  - |  - |  - |  - | No trophy |
| Treasure Hauler |  - |  - |  - |  - |  - |  - |  - |  - |  - |
| Ultimate | #1 | Broad | Expert | Sublime | Revered | Exalted | Transcendent | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Drinker |  - |  - |  - |  - |  - |  - |  - |  - |
| Hearts Player |  - |  - |  - |  - |  - |  - |  - |  - |
| Poker Player |  - |  - |  - |  - |  - |  - |  - |  - |
| Spades Player |  - |  - |  - |  - |  - |  - |  - |  - |
| Treasure Drop Player |  - |  - |  - |  - |  - |  - |  - |  - |
| Ultimate | #1 | Broad | Expert | Sublime | Revered | Exalted | Transcendent | Incredible | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Alchemist |  - |  - |  - |  - |  - |  - |  - |  - |  - |
| Blacksmith |  - |  - |  - |  - |  - |  - |  - |  - |  - |
| Distiller |  - |  - |  - |  - |  - |  - |  - |  - |  - |
| Forager |  - |  - |  - |  - |  - |  - |  - |  - |  - |
| Shipwright |  - |  - |  - |  - |  - |  - |  - |  - |  - |
| Weaver |  - |  - |  - |  - |  - |  - |  - |  - |  - |
| Bilging |  Silver Crab - 100 crabs cleared |  Golden Crab - 1,000 crabs cleared |  Bejeweled Crab - 5,000 crabs cleared |  Diamond Crab - 20,000 crabs cleared |
|---|---|---|---|---|
 Boots of Bilging - Sublime or higher experience and Able standing in Bilging. | ||||
| Carpentry |  An Eye for Grain - 100 grain bonuses earned |  Grain Adept - 2,000 grain bonuses earned |  Grain Guru - 5,000 grain bonuses earned |  Wizard of Woodgrain - 20,000 grain bonuses earned |
| Duty navigation |  Astral Anchor - 100 constellations completed |  Heavenly Hook - 1,000 constellations completed |  Celestial Sloop - 2,500 constellations completed |  Radiant Jolly Roger - 10,000 constellations completed |
| Gunning |  Silver Cannon - 1,000 cannons filled |  Golden Cannon - 10,000 cannons filled |  Bejeweled Cannon - 100,000 cannons filled |  Diamond Cannon - 250,000 cannons filled |
| Patching |  Bronze Eyelet - 100 grommets used |  Resplendent Ring - 2,000 grommets used |  Golden Grommet - Unknown grommets used |  Crystal Cringle - Unknown grommets used |
| Rigging |  Brass Braid - 100 wild pieces used |  Splendid Soutache - 2,000 wild pieces used |  Lustrous Loop - Unknown wild pieces used |  Platinum Plait - Unknown wild pieces used |
| Rumble |  Featherweight of Sprinkles - 1,000 balls sprinkled |  Middleweight of Sprinkles - 5,000 balls sprinkled |  Heavyweight of Sprinkles - 25,000 balls sprinkled |  Champion of Sprinkles - 100,000 balls sprinkled |
 Featherweight of Strikes - 200 rumble strikes |  Middleweight of Strikes - 1,000 rumble strikes |  Heavyweight of Strikes - 5,000 rumble strikes |  Champion of Strikes - 20,000 rumble strikes | |
| Sailing |  Jack-Tar - 200 targets completed |  Savvy Sailor - 4,000 targets completed |  Seasoned Old Salt - 10,000 targets completed |  Masterful Sea Dog - 40,000 targets completed |
| Swordfighting |  Swordsman of Sprinkles - 1,000 blocks sprinkled |  Adept Swordsman of Sprinkles - 5,000 blocks sprinkled |  Elite Swordsman of Sprinkles - 25,000 blocks sprinkled |  Blademaster of Sprinkles - 100,000 blocks sprinkled |
 Swordsman of Strikes - 200 swordfight strikes |  Adept Swordsman of Strikes - 1,000 swordfight strikes |  Elite Swordsman of Strikes - 5,000 swordfight strikes |  Blademaster of Strikes - 20,000 swordfight strikes |
 First Gold - First gold nugget foraged |  Gold Digger - 100 gold nuggets foraged |
 Jade Monkey - Winning one million PoE in a single pot. |
 Dread Masterpiece - Contributing in-game art content |  Gilded Egg - Submitting a winning egg design |
 Antediluvian Conch - First antediluvian conch opened |  Daffodil - 10 solo portraits commissioned. |  A Dozen Daffodils - 120 solo portraits commissioned. |  Marauder o' Many Faces - Unknown |
 Jinxed Idol - Unknown criteria (awarded at login time). |  Winged Shoes - 1,000 whisks from whisking potions. |  Full Steam Ahead - Win a sea battle while playing on Steam, or on the same ship as a Steam user. |  Map and Brew - Buying 100 drinks for an old salt at an inn. |
 A Collector o' Note - Trading in 100 Trinkets at the Trading post. |  An Avid Collector - Trading in 2500 Trinkets at the Trading post. |  Magnus Congregor - Trading in 25,000 Trinkets at the Trading post. |
| 1st place | 2nd place | 3rd place | 4th place | 5th place | 6th place | 7th place | 8th place | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2007 Halloween events |  Book of Zombie - |  Skelly Grimoire - |  Undead Nunchaku - |  Bone Lute - |  Eye of the Zombie - |  Zombie Chowder - | No trophies | |
| 2007 Holiday events |  Sleigh Captain - |  Booty-filled Stocking - |  Sack of Flight Powder - |  Ornamental Cabin Elf - |  Reindeer Feed - |  Nose-glow Wax - |  Proto-diamond - |  Bushel of Reindeer Apples - |
| 2008 Olympic Games events |  Laurels of Victory - |  Glittering Gold - |  Shining Silver - |  Bold Bronze - |  Laurel of Poison Ivy - | No trophies | ||
| 2008 Halloween events |  Ye Golden Chained Saw - |  Silver Cannon Ball - |  Torch and Trident - |  Hammer and Sharpened Pegleg - |  Sanctified Bilge Water - | No trophies | ||
| 2008 Holiday events |  Rolling Pin of the Frost Giants - |  Jack Frost's Egg Blizzarder - |  Old Man Winter's Cookie Cutters - |  Snow Maiden's Spatulas - |  Father Frost's Muffin Tray - |  Yeti's Soiled Apron - | No trophies | |
| 2009 Halloween events |  Gilded Sanguinary Chalice - |  Silver Daybed - |  Bronze Nocturne - |  Vampiric Signet Ring - |  Tinted Spectacles - |  Wax Fangs - | No trophies | |
| 2009 Holiday events |  Prize Holiday Goose - |  Ghostly Brass Door Knocker - |  Abandoned Crutch - | No trophies | ||||
| 2010 Pirate Winter Games |  Laurels of Icy Victory - |  Glacial Gold - |  Shivering Silver - |  Boreal Bronze - |  Laurels of Frostbite - | No trophies | ||
| 2010 Halloween events |  Gilded Spirit Board - |  Silvered Whispering Portrait - |  Bronze Haunted Locket - |  Jar of Ectoplasmic Preserves - | No trophies | |||
| 2010 Holiday events |  Master's Golden Hammer - |  Journeyman's Silver Saw - |  Craftsman's Bronze Chisel - |  Apprentice's Stuffing and Paints - |  Drudge's Rejected Toy Parts - | No trophies | ||
| 2011 Summer events |  Bootlicker's Banner - |  Emperor's Vintage - |  Imperial Eye Patch - |  Ye Royal Bilge Bucket - | No trophies | |||
| 2011 Halloween events |  Savage Majesty - |  Frenzy Rising - |  The Call of the Wild - |  Dormant Beast - |  Fuzzy Slippers - | No trophies | ||
| 2011 Holiday events |  Golden Trailblazer - |  Silver Explorer - |  Bronze Adventurer - |  Hardwood Pathfinder - |  Ye Olde Weevily Biscuit - | No trophies | ||
| 2012 Olympic Games events |  Lunch with Zeus - |  Golden Sandals of Hermes - |  Silver Discus of Heracles - |  Bronze Javelin of Procris - |  Hit the Showers - | No trophies | ||
| 2014 Holiday events |  Snowbeard Victorious - |  Gilded Harpoons - |  Silver Spyglass - |  Bronze Booties - |  Kraken Bait - | No trophies | ||
| 2015 Holiday events |  Primary Pygoscelis - |  Secondary Spheniscus - |  Tertiary Tereingaornis - |  Roly Poly Fish Bucket - | No trophies | |||
| 2016 Olympic Games events |  Flame of Ultimate Victory - |  Flame of Gilded Courage - |  Flame of Silver Spirit - |  Flame of Bronze Resolve - |  Embers of Defeat - | No trophies | ||
| 2016 Holiday events |  Cratchit's Raise - |  Fezziwig's Punch Bowl - |  Fragment of Underdone Potato - | No trophies | ||||
| 2017 Halloween events |  Diamond Vampire Fangs - |  Gilded Werewolf Claw - |  Silvered Skellie Bone - |  Bronzed Zombie Foot - |  Spectre Snacks - | No trophies | ||
| 2017 Holiday events |  Snowbeard Victorious 2 - |  Diamond Candy Cane - |  Golden Elf Hat - |  Silver Mitten - |  Chum Bucket - | No trophies | ||
| 2018 Halloween events |  Gilded Eternal Hourglass - |  Silver Clattering Chain - |  Bronze Self-writing Quill - |  Ectoplasm and Cheese on Rye - | No trophies | |||
| 2018 Holiday events |  Fish-gobbler's Golden Guilder - |  Subantarctic Silver Dollar - |  Herring Bone Haypenny - |  Orca Repellent - | No trophies | |||
| 2019 Halloween events |  Growling Golden Gore-spiller - |  Snarling Silver Scent-stalker - |  Big Bad Bronze Beastie - |  Misleadingly Mundane Monster - |  Extra Extra Rare Steak - | No trophies | ||
| 2020 Halloween events |  The Count's Golden Medallion - |  Lucy's Silver Cameo - |  Van Helsing's Bronze Hammer - |  Renfield's Knickers - | No trophies | |||
| 2020 Holiday events |  Golden Gourmet - |  Argent Assembler - |  Bronze Baker - |  Common Cook - |  Icy Hairnet - | No trophies | ||
| 2021 Summer Games |  Oracle's Eternal Flame - |  Golden Pegasus Shield - |  Dryad's Silver Lyre - |  Bronze Centaur Kylix - |  Drunken Silenus - | No trophies | ||
| 2021 Halloween Events |  Diamond Vampirate - |  Golden Werewolf - |  Silver Skelly - |  Bronze Zombie - |  Steamed Homunculus - | No trophies | ||
| 2021 Holiday events |  Ye Diamond Potato - |  Ye Golden Parsnip - |  Ye Silver Sock - |  Ye Bronze Bits n' Pieces - |  A Mighty Strong Cuppa Joe - | No trophies | ||
| 2022 Halloween events |  Golden Leg o' Man - |  Silver Stag Haunch - |  Bronze Boar Ham - |  Wolfsbane Puddin' - | No trophies | |||
| 2022 Holiday events |  Golden Ghosty Cane - |  Silver Ecto-cocoa - |  Bronze Gingerdead Cookie - |  Phantom Fruitcake - | No trophies | |||
| 2023 Halloween events |  House o' Bricks - |  House o' Sticks - |  House o' Straw - |  Big Bad Broth - | No trophies | |||
| 2023 Holiday events |  Golden Cup o' Cheer - |  Figgy Puddin' on a Silver Platter - |  Bronze Bucket o' Shortbread - |  Sugar Plum Found on the Floor - | No trophies | |||
| 2024 Summer Games |  Adamant Awesomeness - |  Golden Greatness - |  Silver Superiority - |  Bronze Brilliance - |  Even Drunker Silenus - | No trophies | ||
| 2024 Holiday events |  Golden Goo-slinger - |  Silver Sludge-meister - |  Bronze Bilgegargle - |  Slimed Stocking Cap - | No trophies |
 Candy Corn - 1 battle won |  Fist Full o' Treats - 5 battles won |  A Good Haul - 35 battles won |  Overstuffed Pillowcase - 113 battles won |
 Ghost's Purse - 3 opponents defeated |  Eldritch Plunder - 100 opponents defeated |  Boogeyman's Bounty - 750 opponents defeated |  Ghost King's Hoard - 2500 opponents defeated |
 Assembled Model Frigate - First model ship assembled. |  Realistic Rocking Pony - First rocking pony assembled. |  Unwrapped Imperial Soldier - First toy imperial soldier assembled. | |
 Toy Collection - 4 toys assembled |  Toy Bounty - 10 toys assembled |  Pile o' Presents - 30 toys assembled |  Santa's Sack - 100 toys assembled |
 Palm Grease - 1,000 PoE won |  Bribery Box - 5,000 PoE won |  Payoff Purse - 30,000 PoE won |  Toady's Treasure Trove - 112,000 PoE won |
 Sailing Rations Kit - First sailing rations kit assembled. |  Ship Materials Kit - First ship materials kit assembled. |  Survival Supply Kit - First survival supply kit assembled. | |
 Patchy Provisions - 4 kits assembled |  Respectable Replenishment - 10 kits assembled |  Extensive Equipage - 30 kits assembled |  Supreme Stockpile - 100 kits assembled |
 Adorominable Snow Man - First yeti doll assembled. |  Pea Shooter - First toy cannon assembled. |  Rum Pum Pum Rum - First small drum assembled. |
 Octo Bomber - First Octo Bomber assembled. |  Gunwhale - First Gunwhale assembled. |  Toy Soldier Scout - First Toy Soldier Scout assembled. | |
 Humble Bundle - 4 toys assembled. |  Boastful Barrel - 10 toys assembled. |  Cracking Crates - 30 toys assembled. |  Snowbeard's Sleigh - 100 toys assembled. |
 Snowbeard Avenger - Being on a team that sucessfully bombs the Frost Kraken |
 Ancient Sealing Tablet - First Ancient Tablet assembled. |  Ceremonial Crystal Seal - First Crystal Seal assembled. |  Penguin Phaseal Statue - First Penguin Idol assembled. | |
 Loose Seal - 4 artefacts assembled. |  Rope Seal - 10 artefacts assembled. |  Steel Seal - 30 artefacts assembled. |  Gilded Seal - 100 artefacts assembled. |
 Sealed the Deal - First Imperial outpost defeated. |
 Ye Jolly Taffy - 1 battle won |  Pocket Full o' Goodies - 5 battles won |  Bucket o' Loot - 35 battles won |  Bountiful Treat Bowl - 113 battles won |
 Blast Monkey - First Blast Monkey assembled. |  Pirate Playset - First Pirate Playset assembled. |  Sky-shark Glider - First Sky-shark Glider assembled. | |
 Handful o' Toys - 4 toys assembled. |  Gathering o' Gifts - 10 toys assembled. |  Plenty o' Packages - 30 toys assembled. |  Boatload o' Fun - 100 toys assembled. |
 Slithery Keepsake - Being on a team that sucessfully bombs the Frost Kraken |
 Ghost Gem - 5 opponents defeated |  Spirit Stone Sampler - 100 opponents defeated |  Revenant Rock Receptacle - 750 opponents defeated |  Barrel of Bugaboo Baubles - 2500 opponents defeated |
 X'Ukara Statue - First X'ukara Statue assembled. |  Seal Fetish - First Seal Fetish assembled. |  Penguin Fetish - First Penguin Fetish assembled. |  Sealperial Thumper - |
 Stone Symbol - 4 artefacts assembled. |  Bronze Badge - 10 artefacts assembled. |  Sterling Sigil - 30 artefacts assembled. |  Golden Glyph - 100 artefacts assembled. |
 Aye Think I Can, Aye Think I Can - First Loot Train furniture assembled. |  Fuzzy Freebooter - First Hobby Pony furniture assembled. |  Here comes ye Cavalry - First Pirate Teddy furniture assembled. |
 Rumnog - First Rum Nog assembled. |  Gingerbread Sloop - First Gingerbread Sloop assembled. |  Chocolate Doubloons - First Chocolate Doubloons assembled. | |
 Platter o' Delights - 4 food items assembled. |  Basket o' Munchies - 10 food items assembled. |  Tub o' Tastiness - 30 food items assembled. |  Caloric Overload - 100 food items assembled. |
 All Day Sucker - 1 battle won |  Bubble Pop - 5 battles won |  Wee Lolly - 35 battles won |  Grammas's Hard Candy - 113 battles won |
 Mister Potato Sled - First Mister Potato Sled assembled. |  Sock Skunky - First Sock Skunky assembled. |  Parsnip Patch Doll - First Parsnip Patch Doll assembled. | |
 A Fistful o' Fun - 4 toy items assembled. |  A Nice Pile o' Playthings - 10 toy items assembled. |  A Healthy Heap o' Happiness - 30 toy items assembled. |  Toytastic Truckload - 100 toy items assembled. |
 Single Snacker - 1 cookie traded in. |  A Couple o' Crunchers - 20 cookies traded in. |  Generous Gingies - 60 cookies traded in. |  Pastry Pileup - 100 cookies traded in. |
 Single Slime - 1 goop traded in. |  Oozy Duo - 20 goop traded in. |  Sludge Bucket - 60 goop traded in. |  Tub o'Goo - 100 goop traded in. |
 Fall n' Crossbones - Claiming a 2008 Halloween Promotion Bonanza gift in October, 2008. |  Crimson and Jade Statuette - Claiming a July Promotion gift in July, 2009. |  One-Eyed Maple - Claiming an All Hallows' Spooktacular Promotion gift in October, 2009. |  Hearty Harvest - Claiming a Harvest Celebration Promotion gift in November, 2009. |  Snowflake o' Piracy - Claiming a Winter Mystery Promotion gift in January, 2010. |
 Budding Blade - Claiming a Spring Surprise Promotion gift in March, 2010. |  Bloomin' Skull - Claiming a May Mystery Promotion gift in May, 2010. |  Skull n' Crosscones - Claiming a Banana Box Promotion gift in July, 2010. |  Ye Olde Harvest Moon - Claiming a Chocolate Mystery Box Promotion gift in September to October, 2010. |  Horn of Plunder - Claiming a Harvest Mystery Box Promotion gift in November, 2010. |
 Ice Skullpture - Claiming an Ice Box Promotion gift in January, 2011. |  Jolly Shamrocks - Claiming a Lucky Box Promotion gift in March, 2011. |  Banana Blade - Claiming a Banana Mystery Box Promotion gift in May, 2011. |  Pirate Plumder - Claiming a Plum Mystery Box Promotion gift in July, 2011. |  Chocolate Harvest - Claiming a Chocolate Harvest gift in September, 2011. |
 Rogue Vintage - Claiming a Harvest Mystery Box Promotion gift in November, 2011. |  Snow-ho-ho and a Bottle of Rum! - Claiming an Ice Box Promotion gift in January, 2012. |  Spring Training - Claiming a Lucky Box Promotion gift in March, 2012. |  Bone-ana Split - Claiming a Banana Box Promotion gift in May, 2012. |  Plum-bob Quadrant - Claiming a Plum Mystery Box Promotion gift in July, 2012. |
 Yococoa Cake - Claiming a Chocolate Mystery Box Promotion gift in September, 2012. |  Pinot Yarrr - Claiming a Wine Mystery Box Promotion gift in November, 2012. |  Outdated Calendarrr - Claiming an Ice Box Promotion gift in January, 2013. |  Jolly Green Roger - Claiming a Spring Green Promotion gift in March, 2013. |  Banana Bandana Bonanza - Claiming a Banana Box Promotion gift in May, 2013. |
 Plum Rum - Claiming a Plum Box Promotion gift in July, 2013. |  Choco Shako - Claiming a Chocolate Mystery Box Promotion gift in September, 2013. |  Dennis - Claiming a Wine Mystery Box Promotion gift in November, 2013. |  Icy Blades - Claiming an Ice Box Promotion gift in January, 2014. |  Green Jack - Claiming a Spring Green Mystery Box Promotion gift in March, 2014. |
 Banana King Figurine - Claiming a Banana Box Promotion gift in May, 2014. |  Beach Plum - Claiming a Plum Box Promotion gift in July, 2014. |  Choctopus - Claiming a Chocolate Box Promotion gift in September, 2014. |  Whinin' Cheese - Claiming a Wine Mystery Box Promotion gift in November, 2014. |  Snowy Swashbuckler - Claiming an Ice Box Promotion gift in January, 2015. |
 Green Spring - Claiming a Spring Green Box Promotion gift in March, 2015. |  Swinging Banana - Claiming a Banana Mystery Box Promotion gift in May, 2015. |  Plumscreen Lotion - Claiming a Plum Box Promotion gift in July, 2015. |  Eggcellent Chocolate Surprise - Claiming a Chocolate Box Promotion gift in September, 2015. |  Vinyarrrd Fresh - Claiming a Wine Box Promotion gift in November, 2015. |
 Ice Chest - Claiming an Ice Box Promotion gift in January, 2016. |  Rites of Spring - Claiming a Spring Green Box Promotion gift in March, 2016. |  Banana-ramma - Claiming a Banana Mystery Box Promotion gift in May 2016. |  Plum in the Sun - Claiming a Plum Box Promotion gift in July 2016. |  Choco Skull - Claiming a Chocolate Box Promotion gift in September 2016. |
 Grape Ape Wine - Claiming a Wine Box Promotion gift in November 2016. |  Frozen Tricorne - Claiming an Ice Box Promotion gift in January 2017. |  Ye Dread Sprout - Claiming a Spring Green Box Promotion gift in March 2017. |  Banana Bandana on Nana - Claiming a Banana Mystery Box Promotion gift in May 2017. |  Plum Tuckered Out - Claiming a Plum Box Promotion gift in July 2017. |
 Chunk o' Obsidian - Claiming a Dark Seas Battle Box Promotion gift in September 2017. |  Fudgefoot Print - Claiming a Chocolate Box Promotion gift in September 2017. |  Yohoho and a Jug o' Merlot - Claiming a Wine Box Promotion gift in November 2017. |  Frosted Frigate - Claiming an Ice Box Promotion gift in January 2018. |  Blossoming Banner - Claiming a Spring Green Box Promotion gift in March 2018. |
 Banana Hand - Claiming a Banana Mystery Box Promotion gift in May 2018. |  Plum Crazy - Claiming a Plum Box Promotion gift in July 2018. |  Choklit Chomper - Claiming a Chocolate Box Promotion gift in September 2018. |  Pirate's Press - Claiming a Wine Box Promotion gift in November 2018. |  Hot Co-ho-ho-coa - Claiming an Ice Box Promotion gift in January 2019. |
 Spring Wheel - Claiming a Spring Green Box Promotion gift in March 2019. |  Banana Cabana - Claiming a Banana Mystery Box Promotion gift in May 2019. |  Plum the Depths - Claiming a Plum Box Promotion gift in July 2019. |  Anchored by Chocolate - Claiming a Chocolate Box Promotion gift in September 2019. |  Corsair's Chianti - Claiming a Wine Box Promotion gift in November 2019. |
 Slice o' Ice - Claiming an Ice Box Promotion gift in January 2020. |  Green Grog - Claiming a Spring Green Box Promotion gift in March 2020. |  Banana on the Savannah - Claiming a Banana Box Promotion gift in May 2020. |  Beach Curiosity - Claiming a Tempest Box Promotion gift in June 2020. |  Plum Chewin’ Gum - Claiming a Plum Box Promotion gift in July 2020. |
 Choc Full o’ Loot - Claiming a Chocolate Box Promotion gift in September 2020. |  Captain’s Case - Claiming a Wine Box Promotion gift in November 2020. |  Frozen Yohohogurt - Claiming an Ice Box Promotion gift in January 2021. |  Ye Green Cap'n - Claiming a Spring Green Box Promotion gift in March 2021. |  Banana on a Pianna - Claiming a Banana Box Promotion gift in May 2021. |
 Plum Chum - Claiming a Plum Box Promotion gift in July 2021. |  Ye Choklit Raider - Claiming a Chocolate Box Promotion gift in September 2021. |  Winkin' Flittermouse - Claiming a Sinister Box Promotion gift in October 2021. |  Corsair's Cup - Claiming a Wine Box Promotion gift in November 2021. |  Grog Pop - Claiming a Ice Box Promotion gift in January 2022. |
 Emerald Astrolabe - Claiming a Spring Green Box Promotion gift in March 2022. |  Banana Gettin' a Tanna - Claiming a Banana Box Promotion gift in May 2022. |  Plum Chum with a Side o' Rum - Claiming a Plum Box Promotion gift in July 2022. |  Glop o'Glopster Goop - Claiming a Tempest Box Promotion gift in August 2022. |  Cocoa-nutty Cocktail - Claiming a Chocolate Box Promotion gift in September 2022. |
 Shadowberry Skull - Claiming a Sinister Box Promotion gift in October 2022. |  Cabernet Cutlass - Claiming a Wine Box Promotion gift in November 2022. |  Ye Jolly Snowball - Claiming a Ice Box Promotion gift in January 2023. |  Ye Laughing Pooka - Claiming a Spring Green Box Promotion gift in March 2023. |  Banana with a Planna - Claiming a Banana Box Promotion gift in May 2023. |
 Puzzlin' with Aplum - Claiming a Plum Box Promotion gift in July 2023. |  Shark King's Things - Claiming a Tempest Box Promotion gift in August 2023. |  Deliciously Deciduous - Claiming a Chocolate Box Promotion gift in September 2023. |  Ye Darkling Gull - Claiming a Sinister Box Promotion gift in October 2023. |  Sea Satyr's Rhyton - Claiming a Wine Box Promotion gift in November 2023. |
 Ye Ice Cap'n - Claiming a Ice Box Promotion gift in January 2024. |  Ye Colorful Draught - Claiming a Spring Green Box Promotion gift in March 2024. |  Banana Pirann-nha - Claiming a Banana Box Promotion gift in May 2024. |  The Plum Frum Byzantium - Claiming a Plum Box Promotion gift in July 2024. |  Ye Salty Picaroon - Claiming a Tempest Box Promotion gift in August 2024. |
 Ye Cocoa Carp - Claiming a Chocolate Box Promotion gift in September 2024. |  Penumbral Pumpkin - Claiming a Sinister Box Promotion gift in October 2024. |  Tyme fer Wyne - Claiming a Wine Box Promotion gift in November 2024. |  Ye Snowy Sailfish - Claiming a Ice Box Promotion gift in January 2025. |  Merrow's Comb - Claiming a Spring Green Box Promotion gift in March 2025. |
| Jump to: 2009 - 2010 - 2011 - 2012 - 2013 - 2014 - 2015 - 2016 - 2017 - 2018 - 2019 - 2020 - 2021 - 2022 - 2023 - 2024 - 2025 |
| Monthly | Seasonal | Annual | ||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| No trophy |  Seal o' Piracy: August 2009 - Complete a challenge for the August 2009 Sweepstakes. |  Seal o' Piracy: September 2009 - Visit three of the necessary destinations. |  Seal o' Piracy: October 2009 - Defeat a group of skellies and zombies once each. |  Seal o' Piracy: November 2009 - Complete a session of six different duty puzzles. |  Seal o' Piracy: December 2009 - Complete ten expeditions. | No trophy |  Seal o' Piracy: Autumn 2009 - Win the September, October, and November 2009 seals. |  Seal o' Piracy: 2009 - Win all 2009 seals. |
 Seal o' Piracy: January 2010 - Complete a session of every parlor/inn game, except poker. |  Seal o' Piracy: February 2010 - Visit three of the necessary destinations. |  Seal o' Piracy: March 2010 - Complete twenty-five sea battles. |  Seal o' Piracy: April 2010 - Complete a session of four different labor puzzles, except Foraging. |  Seal o' Piracy: May 2010 - Complete a non-Navy session of five different duty puzzles, except Treasure Haul. |  Seal o' Piracy: June 2010 - Reach the melee in three Brigand King battles at sea. |  Seal o' Piracy: Winter 2010 - Win the December 2009, January 2010, and February 2010 seals. |  Seal o' Piracy: Spring 2010 - Win the March, April, and May 2010 seals |  Seal o' Piracy: 2010 - Win all 2010 seals. |
 Seal o' Piracy: July 2010 - Complete thirty sea battles; Battles involving a junk are worth triple. |  Seal o' Piracy: August 2010 - Play any twelve puzzles, except battle navigation. |  Seal o' Piracy: September 2010 - Visit four of the necessary destinations. |  Seal o' Piracy: October 2010 - Complete ten sea battles against brigands, and ten against barbarians. |  Seal o' Piracy: November 2010 - Complete twelve parlor game sessions (poker does not count) |  Seal o' Piracy: December 2010 - Complete a non-Navy session of five different duty puzzles, except Treasure Haul. |  Seal o' Piracy: Summer 2010 - Win the June, July, and August 2010 seals |  Seal o' Piracy: Autumn 2010 - Win the September, October, and November 2010 seals. | |
 Seal o' Piracy: January 2011 - Defeat a group of skellies and zombies once each. |  Seal o' Piracy: February 2011 - Complete four different expeditions (Brigand Kings and Merchant Hunts don't count) |  Seal o' Piracy: March 2011 - Participate in five tournaments. |  Seal o' Piracy: April 2011 - Complete twenty-five sea battles. |  Seal o' Piracy: May 2011 - Reach the melee in three Brigand King battles at sea. |  Seal o' Piracy: June 2011 - Complete a session of four labor puzzles. |  Seal o' Piracy: Winter 2011 - Win the December 2010, January 2011, and February 2011 seals. |  Seal o' Piracy: Spring 2011 - Win the March, April, and May 2011 seals. |  Seal o' Piracy: 2011 - Win all 2011 seals. |
 Seal o' Piracy: July 2011 - Visit two of the three Sea Monster locations. |  Seal o' Piracy: August 2011 - Complete a session of five different duty puzzles. |  Seal o' Piracy: September 2011 - Complete four different expeditions. |  Seal o' Piracy: October 2011 - Defeat two of the three monster types in a fray: skellies, zombies, or werewolves. |  Seal o' Piracy: November 2011 - Complete twelve parlor game sessions (poker does not count) |  Seal o' Piracy: December 2011 - Fight in three Brigand King melees at sea. |  Seal o' Piracy: Summer 2011 - Win the June, July, and August 2011 seals |  Seal o' Piracy: Autumn 2011 - Win the September, October and November 2011 seals. | |
 Seal o' Piracy: January 2012 - Face ten brigands and ten barbarians in sea battle. |  Seal o' Piracy: February 2012 - Complete a non-Navy session of five different duty puzzles. |  Seal o' Piracy: March 2012 - Participate in five tournaments. |  Seal o' Piracy: April 2012 - Visit two of the three Sea Monster locations. |  Seal o' Piracy: May 2012 - Perform one action that earns the pirate in question Patron Reputation. |  Seal o' Piracy: June 2012 - Perform two different actions that earns the pirate in question Explorer Reputation. |  Seal o' Piracy: Winter 2012 - Win the December 2011, January 2012, and February 2012 seals. |  Seal o' Piracy: Spring 2012 - Win the March, April, and May 2012 seals. |  Seal o' Piracy: 2012 - Win all the 2012 seals. |
 Seal o' Piracy: July 2012 - Perform two different actions that earns the pirate in question Conqueror Reputation. |  Seal o' Piracy: August 2012 - Complete twelve parlor game sessions. |  Seal o' Piracy: September 2012 - Fight in three Brigand King melees at sea. |  Seal o' Piracy: October 2012 - Defeat two of the three roving monster types (skellies, zombies, and werewolves). |  Seal o' Piracy: November 2012 - Complete a session of four labor puzzles. |  Seal o' Piracy: December 2012 - Complete twenty-five sea battles. |  Seal o' Piracy: Autumn 2012 - Win the September, October and November 2012 seals. |  Seal o' Piracy: Summer 2012 - Win the June, July, and August 2012 seals | |
 Seal o' Piracy: January 2013 - Face ten brigands and ten barbarians in sea battle |  Seal o' Piracy: February 2013 - Complete any two different expeditions. |  Seal o' Piracy: March 2013 - Participate in five tournaments. |  Seal o' Piracy: April 2013 - Engage in melees with three Brigand Kings. |  Seal o' Piracy: May 2013 - Complete twenty sea battles. |  Seal o' Piracy: June 2013 - Complete five different duties on a non-Navy vessel. |  Seal o' Piracy: Winter 2013 - Win the December 2012, January 2013, and February 2013 seals. |  Seal o' Piracy: Spring 2013 - Win the March, April, and May 2013 seals. |  Seal o' Piracy: 2013 - Win all the 2013 seals. |
 Seal o' Piracy: July 2013 - Complete twelve parlor game sessions. |  Seal o' Piracy: August 2013 - Complete four different expeditions |  Seal o' Piracy: September 2013 - Perform two different actions that earn the pirate in question Conqueror Reputation. |  Seal o' Piracy: October 2013 - Defeat one group of skellies and one group of zombies. |  Seal o' Piracy: November 2013 - Complete a session of four different crafting puzzles. |  Seal o' Piracy: December 2013 - Complete thirty sea battles. Sea battles involving a longship are worth triple. |  Seal o' Piracy: Autumn 2013 - Win the September, October, and November 2013 seals. |  Seal o' Piracy: Summer 2013 - Win the June, July, and August 2013 seals. | |
 Seal o' Piracy: January 2014 - Complete three sea battles involving a junk and three involving a fanchuan. |  Seal o' Piracy: February 2014 - Complete one buried treasure expedition. |  Seal o' Piracy: March 2014 - Participate in four tournaments. |  Seal o' Piracy: April 2014 - Complete three actions that contribute to Explorer reputation. |  Seal o' Piracy: May 2014 - Complete the melee stage of 3 sea battles that involve Brigand Kings. |  Seal o' Piracy: June 2014 - Complete any five expeditions. |  Seal o' Piracy: Winter 2014 - Win the December 2013, January 2014, and February 2014 seals. |  Seal o' Piracy: Spring 2014 - Win the March, April, and May 2014 seals. |  Seal o' Piracy: 2014 - Win all the 2014 seals. |
 Seal o' Piracy: July 2014 - Complete 30 sea battles. Sea battles involving a cutter are worth triple. |  Seal o' Piracy: August 2014 - Complete 10 parlor games. |  Seal o' Piracy: September 2014 - Complete one session of 4 different crafting puzzles. |  Seal o' Piracy: October 2014 - Fight the graveyard in Haunted Seas 3 times. |  Seal o' Piracy: November 2014 - Completing two foraging sessions outside of the Cursed Isles |  Seal o' Piracy: December 2014 - Complete a non-Navy session of 5 different duty puzzles. |  Seal o' Piracy: Summer 2014 - Win the June, July, and August 2014 seals. |  Seal o' Piracy: Autumn 2014 - Win the September, October, and November 2014 seals. | |
 Seal o' Piracy: January 2015 - Complete ten sea battles against brigands, and ten against barbarians. |  Seal o' Piracy: February 2015 - Complete 2 different expeditions (Imperial, Viking, Buried Treasure, or Shipwreck). |  Seal o' Piracy: March 2015 - Participate in four tournaments. |  Seal o' Piracy: April 2015 - Engage in melee with 3 Brigand Kings. |  Seal o' Piracy: May 2015 - Complete 20 sea battles. |  Seal o' Piracy: June 2015 - Perform 1 action that earns your pirate Patron Reputation. |  Seal o' Piracy: Winter 2015 - Win the December 2014, January 2015, and February 2015 seals. |  Seal o' Piracy: Spring 2015 - Win the March, April, and May 2015 seals. |  Seal o' Piracy: 2015 - Win all the 2015 seals. |
 Seal o' Piracy: July 2015 - Perform 2 different actions that earn your pirate Conqueror Reputation. |  Seal o' Piracy: August 2015 - Complete 10 parlor games. |  Seal o' Piracy: September 2015 - Complete 4 different crafting sessions. |  Seal o' Piracy: October 2015 - Complete two actions to add to yer explorer reputation. |  Seal o' Piracy: November 2015 - Complete two sessions of foraging. (Cursed Isles foraging does not count.) |  Seal o' Piracy: December 2015 - Complete non-Navy sessions of five (5) different duty puzzles. |  Seal o' Piracy: Summer 2015 - Win the June, July, and August 2015 seals. |  Seal o' Piracy: Autumn 2015 - Win the September, October, and November 2015 seals. | |
 Seal o' Piracy: January 2016 - Complete 10 sea battles against brigands and 10 sea battles against barbarians. |  Seal o' Piracy: February 2016 - Complete 2 different expeditions (Imperial Outpost, Viking Defense, Buried Treasure Atoll, or Lost Shipwreck). |  Seal o' Piracy: March 2016 - Participate in five tournaments. |  Seal o' Piracy: April 2016 - Engage in melees with three Brigand Kings. |  Seal o' Piracy: May 2016 - Complete 20 sea battles. |  Seal o' Piracy: June 2016 - Complete a non-Navy session of 5 different duty puzzles. |  Seal o' Piracy: Winter 2016 - Win the December 2015, January 2016, and February 2016 seals. |  Seal o' Piracy: Spring 2016 - Win the March, April, and May 2016 seals. |  Seal o' Piracy: 2016 - Win all the 2016 seals. |
 Seal o' Piracy: July 2016 - Complete 12 parlor game sessions. |  Seal o' Piracy: August 2016 - Complete 4 different expeditions (Imperial Outpost, Viking Defense, Buried Treasure Atoll, Lost Shipwreck, Yeti, Brigand King). |  Seal o' Piracy: September 2016 - Perform 2 different actions that earn your pirate Conqueror Reputation. |  Seal o' Piracy: October 2016 - Defeat 1 group of skellies and 1 group of zombies. |  Seal o' Piracy: November 2016 - Complete sessions of 4 different crafting puzzles. |  Seal o' Piracy: December 2016 - Complete 30 sea battles. Sea battles involving a Longship (either as your ship or the opponent) count triple! |  Seal o' Piracy: Summer 2016 - Win the June, July, and August 2016 seals. |  Seal o' Piracy: Autumn 2016 - Win the September, October, and November 2016 seals. | |
 Seal o' Piracy: January 2017 - Participate in 3 sea battles involving a Junk and 3 sea battles involving a Fanchuan. (A battle between a Junk and a Fanchuan counts towards both.) |  Seal o' Piracy: February 2017 - Complete 1 buried treasure expedition. |  Seal o' Piracy: March 2017 - Participate in 4 tournaments |  Seal o' Piracy: April 2017 - Complete 3 actions to add to yer explorer reputation! |  Seal o' Piracy: May 2017 - Engage in melees with 3 Brigand Kings. |  Seal o' Piracy: June 2017 - Complete any 5 expeditions. |  Seal o' Piracy: Winter 2017 - Win the December 2016, January 2017, and February 2017 seals. |  Seal o' Piracy: Spring 2017 - Win the March, April, and May 2017 seals. |  Seal o' Piracy: 2017 - Win all the 2017 seals. |
 Seal o' Piracy: July 2017 - Complete 30 sea battles. (Battles involving a cutter count triple.) |  Seal o' Piracy: August 2017 - Complete 10 parlor games. |  Seal o' Piracy: September 2017 - Complete 4 different crafting sessions. |  Seal o' Piracy: October 2017 - Fight the graveyard in Haunted Seas 3 times, win or lose. |  Seal o' Piracy: November 2017 - Complete 2 sessions of foraging. (Foraging while in Cursed Isles does not count.) |  Seal o' Piracy: December 2017 - Complete a non-Navy session of 5 different duty puzzles. |  Seal o' Piracy: Summer 2017 - Win the June, July, and August 2017 seals. |  Seal o' Piracy: Autumn 2017 - Win the September, October, and November 2017 seals. | |
 Seal o' Piracy: January 2018 - Complete 10 sea battles against brigands, and 10 sea battles against barbarians |  Seal o' Piracy: February 2018 - Complete 2 different expeditions (Imperial Outpost, Viking Defense, Buried Treasure Atoll, or Lost Shipwreck) |  Seal o' Piracy: March 2018 - Participate in four tournaments. |  Seal o' Piracy: April 2018 - Engage in melees with 3 Brigand Kings, win or lose. |  Seal o' Piracy: May 2018 - Complete 20 sea battles. |  Seal o' Piracy: June 2018 - Perform 1 action that earns your pirate patron reputation. (There must be at least 10 participants to count.) |  Seal o' Piracy: Winter 2018 - Win the December 2017, January 2018, and February 2018 seals. |  Seal o' Piracy: Spring 2018 - Win the March, April, and May 2018 seals. |  Seal o' Piracy: 2018 - Win all the 2018 seals. |
 Seal o' Piracy: July 2018 - Perform 2 different actions that earn your pirate Conqueror Reputation (Fight BKs, skellies, zombies, or werewolves, or complete IO or Viking raid expeditions.) |  Seal o' Piracy: August 2018 - Complete 10 parlor games. |  Seal o' Piracy: September 2018 - Complete 4 different crafting sessions. |  Seal o' Piracy: October 2018 - Complete 2 actions that add to your explorer reputation. |  Seal o' Piracy: November 2018 - Complete 2 sessions of foraging. |  Seal o' Piracy: December 2018 - Complete non-Navy sessions of five (5) different duty puzzles. |  Seal o' Piracy: Summer 2018 - Win the June, July, and August 2018 seals. |  Seal o' Piracy: Autumn 2018 - Win the September, October, and November 2018 seals. | |
 Seal o' Piracy: January 2019 - Complete 10 sea battles against brigands, and 10 sea battles against barbarians. |  Seal o' Piracy: February 2019 - Complete 2 different expeditions. |  Seal o' Piracy: March 2019 - Participate in 5 different tournaments. |  Seal o' Piracy: April 2019 - Engage in melees with three Brigand Kings. |  Seal o' Piracy: May 2019 - Complete 20 sea battles. |  Seal o' Piracy: June 2019 - Complete a non-Navy session of 5 different duty puzzles. |  Seal o' Piracy: Winter 2019 - Win the December 2018, January 2019, and February 2019 seals. |  Seal o' Piracy: Spring 2019 - Win the March, April, and May 2019 seals. |  Seal o' Piracy: 2019 - Win all the 2019 seals. |
 Seal o' Piracy: July 2019 - Complete 12 parlor game sessions. |  Seal o' Piracy: August 2019 - Complete 4 different expeditions. |  Seal o' Piracy: September 2019 - Perform 2 different actions that earn Conqueror Reputation. |  Seal o' Piracy: October 2019 - Defeat 1 group of skellies and 1 group of zombies. |  Seal o' Piracy: November 2019 - Complete sessions of 4 different crafting puzzles. |  Seal o' Piracy: December 2019 - Complete 30 sea battles. |  Seal o' Piracy: Summer 2019 - Win the June, July, and August 2019 seals. |  Seal o' Piracy: Autumn 2019 - Win the September, October, and November 2019 seals. | |
 Seal o' Piracy: January 2020 - Participate in 3 sea battles involving a Junk and 3 sea battles involving a Fanchuan. |  Seal o' Piracy: February 2020 - Complete 1 buried treasure expedition. |  Seal o' Piracy: March 2020 - Participate in 4 tournaments. |  Seal o' Piracy: April 2020 - Complete 3 actions to add to explorer reputation. |  Seal o' Piracy: May 2020 - Engage in melees with 3 Brigand Kings. |  Seal o' Piracy: June 2020 - Complete any 5 expeditions. |  Seal o' Piracy: Winter 2020 - Win the December 2019, January 2020, and February 2020 seals. |  Seal o' Piracy: Spring 2020 - Win the March, April, and May 2020 seals. |  Seal o' Piracy: 2020 - Win all the 2020 seals. |
 Seal o' Piracy: July 2020 - Complete 30 sea battles. |  Seal o' Piracy: August 2020 - Complete 10 parlor games. |  Seal o' Piracy: September 2020 - Complete 4 different crafting sessions. |  Seal o' Piracy: October 2020 - Fight the graveyard in Haunted Seas 3 times, win or lose. |  Seal o' Piracy: November 2020 - Completing 2 sessions of foraging. (Foraging while in Cursed Isles does not count.) |  Seal o' Piracy: December 2020 - Complete a non-Navy session of 5 different duty puzzles. |  Seal o' Piracy: Summer 2020 - Win the June, July, and August 2020 seals. |  Seal o' Piracy: Autumn 2020 - Win the September, October, and November 2020 seals. | |
 Seal o' Piracy: January 2021 - Complete 10 sea battles against brigands, and 10 sea battles against barbarians. |  Seal o' Piracy: February 2021 - Complete 2 different expeditions. |  Seal o' Piracy: March 2021 - Participate in 4 tournaments. |  Seal o' Piracy: April 2021 - Engage in melees with 3 Brigand Kings. |  Seal o' Piracy: May 2021 - Complete 20 sea battles. |  Seal o' Piracy: June 2021 - Perform 1 action that earns your pirate Patron Reputation. |  Seal o' Piracy: Winter 2021 - Win the December 2020, January 2021, and February 2021 seals. |  Seal o' Piracy: Spring 2021 - Win the March, April, and May 2021 seals. |  Seal o' Piracy: 2021 - Win all the 2021 seals. |
 Seal o' Piracy: July 2021 - Perform 2 different actions that earns your pirate Conqueror Reputation. |  Seal o' Piracy: August 2021 - Completing 10 parlor games. |  Seal o' Piracy: September 2021 - Completing 4 different crafting sessions. |  Seal o' Piracy: October 2021 - Perform 2 actions that earn your pirate Eplorer Reputation. |  Seal o' Piracy: November 2021 - Completing 2 foraging sessions. |  Seal o' Piracy: December 2021 - Completing non-Navy sessions of five different duty puzzles. |  Seal o' Piracy: Summer 2021 - Win the June, July, and August 2021 seals. |  Seal o' Piracy: Autumn 2021 - Win the September, October, and November 2021 seals. | |
 Seal o' Piracy: January 2022 - Complete 10 sea battles against brigands, and 10 sea battles against barbarians. |  Seal o' Piracy: February 2022 - Complete 2 different expeditions. |  Seal o' Piracy: March 2022 - Participate in 5 tournaments. |  Seal o' Piracy: April 2022 - Engage in melees with 3 Brigand Kings. |  Seal o' Piracy: May 2022 - Complete 20 sea battles. |  Seal o' Piracy: June 2022 - Complete a non-Navy session of 5 different duty puzzles. |  Seal o' Piracy: Winter 2022 - Win the December 2021, January 2022, and February 2022 seals. |  Seal o' Piracy: Spring 2022 - Win the March, April, and May 2022 seals. |  Seal o' Piracy: 2022 - Win all the 2022 seals. |
 Seal o' Piracy: July 2022 - Complete 12 parlor game sessions. |  Seal o' Piracy: August 2022 - Complete 4 different expeditions. |  Seal o' Piracy: September 2022 - Perform 2 different actions that earn your pirate Conqueror Reputation. |  Seal o' Piracy: October 2022 - Defeat 1 group of skellies and 1 group of zombies. |  Seal o' Piracy: November 2022 - Complete sessions of 4 different crafting puzzles. |  Seal o' Piracy: December 2022 - Complete 30 sea battles. Longship (yours or opponents) counts triple. |  Seal o' Piracy: Summer 2022 - Win the June, July, and August 2022 seals. |  Seal o' Piracy: Autumn 2022 - Win the September, October, and November 2022 seals. | |
 Seal o' Piracy: January 2023 - 3 sea battles involving a Junk and 3 sea battles involving a Fanchuan. |  Seal o' Piracy: February 2023 - Complete 1 buried treasure expedition. |  Seal o' Piracy: March 2023 - Participate in 4 tournaments. |  Seal o' Piracy: April 2023 - Complete 3 actions to add to yer explorer reputation. |  Seal o' Piracy: May 2023 - Engage in melees with 3 Brigand Kings or Vampirate Vessels. |  Seal o' Piracy: June 2023 - Complete any 5 expeditions. |  Seal o' Piracy: Winter 2023 - Win the December 2022, January 2023, and February 2023 seals. |  Seal o' Piracy: Spring 2023 - Win the March, April, and May 2023 seals. |  Seal o' Piracy: 2023 - Win all the 2023 seals. |
 Seal o' Piracy: July 2023 - Complete 30 sea battles. Sea battles involving a cutter are worth triple. |  Seal o' Piracy: August 2023 - Complete 10 parlor games. |  Seal o' Piracy: September 2023 - Complete 4 different crafting sessions. |  Seal o' Piracy: October 2023 - Fight the graveyard in Haunted Seas 3 times. |  Seal o' Piracy: November 2023 - Complete 2 sessions of foraging. |  Seal o' Piracy: December 2023 - Complete a non-Navy session of 5 different duty puzzles. |  Seal o' Piracy: Summer 2023 - Win the June, July, and August 2023 seals. |  Seal o' Piracy: Autumn 2023 - Win the September, October, and November 2023 seals. | |
 Seal o' Piracy: January 2024 - Complete 10 sea battles against brigands, and 10 sea battles against barbarians. |  Seal o' Piracy: February 2024 - Complete 2 different expeditions. |  Seal o' Piracy: March 2024 - Participate in 4 tournaments. |  Seal o' Piracy: April 2024 - Engage in melee with 3 Brigand Kings. |  Seal o' Piracy: May 2024 - Complete 20 sea battles. |  Seal o' Piracy: June 2024 - Perform 1 action that earns your pirate Patron Reputation. |  Seal o' Piracy: Winter 2024 - Win the December 2023, January 2024, and February 2024 seals. |  Seal o' Piracy: Spring 2024 - Win the March, April, and May 2024 seals. |  Seal o' Piracy: 2024 - Win all the 2024 seals. |
 Seal o' Piracy: July 2024 - Perform 2 different actions that earn your pirate Conqueror Reputation. |  Seal o' Piracy: August 2024 - Complete 10 parlor games. |  Seal o' Piracy: September 2024 - Complete 4 different crafting sessions. |  Seal o' Piracy: October 2024 - Complete 2 actions to add to yer explorer reputation. |  Seal o' Piracy: November 2024 - Complete 2 sessions of foraging. |  Seal o' Piracy: December 2024 - Complete a non-Navy session of 5 different duty puzzles. |  Seal o' Piracy: Summer 2024 - Win the June, July, and August 2024 seals. |  Seal o' Piracy: Autumn 2024 - Win the September, October, and November 2024 seals. | |
 Seal o' Piracy: January 2025 - Complete 10 sea battles against brigands, and 10 sea battles against barbarians. |  Seal o' Piracy: February 2025 - Complete 2 different expeditions. |  Seal o' Piracy: March 2025 - Participate in 5 tournaments. |  Seal o' Piracy: April 2025 - Engage in melee with 3 Brigand Kings. |  Seal o' Piracy: Winter 2025 - Win the December 2024, January 2025, and February 2025 seals. | ||||
 Quinquennial Seal o' Piracy - Win any five annual Seals o' Piracy. |
 Crimson Bill's Plume - The Jailbreak |  Greyghost's Treasure Map - Pirate Hideout |  Greyghost's Treasure - Greyghost's Adventure |
 Seattle Totem - US Meetup, August 2006 |  Bradford Starfish - UK Meetup, February 2007 |  Vegas Dice - US Meetup, July 2007 |  Bodegraven Wheel O' Cheese - Dutch Meetup, August 2008 |  Delftware Cannon - Dutch Meetup, August 2009 |
 Ye Jolly Campfire - Dutch Meetup, July 2013 |  Seattle Bear - US Meetup, January 2017 |  Dutch Tulip - Dutch Meetup, August 2017 |  Der Hahn von Dornhan - German Meetup, August 2019 |
 Pink Heart - Pirates who were greeters on 2006-10-17. |  Ship in a Bottle - A welcome trophy for the Opal Ocean, awarded from a PoEmail sent to Indigo Ocean players, but able to be claimed on any ocean. |  Crimson Banner - Could be claimed by one pirate per account that had a pirate on the Crimson Ocean at the time of the closing announcement. |  Cobalt Banner - Awarded to pirates who were transferred from the Cobalt Ocean to the Cerulean Ocean on 2012-01-31. |
 Hunter Banner - Awarded to pirates who were transferred from the Hunter Ocean to the Emerald Ocean on 2012-01-31. |  Malachite Banner - Awarded to pirates who were transferred from the Malachite Ocean to the Meridian Ocean on 2012-01-31. |  Midnight Banner - Awarded to pirates who were transferred from the Midnight Ocean to the Cerulean Ocean on 2012-01-31. |  Sage Banner - Awarded to pirates who were transferred from the Sage Ocean to the Emerald Ocean on 2012-01-31. |
 Viridian Banner - Awarded to pirates who were transferred from the Viridian Ocean to the Meridian Ocean on 2012-01-31. |  X Marks the Spot - Awarded to pirates who claimed a Decennium Box between late October and early November, 2012. |  Unchiseled Potential - Substantial participation in the Grand Crafting Puzzle Project. |
 First Order of the Jolly Roger - One year |  Second Order of the Jolly Roger - Two years |  Third Order of the Jolly Roger - Three years |  Fourth Order of the Jolly Roger - Four years |  Fifth Order of the Jolly Roger - Five years |
 Sixth Order of the Jolly Roger - Six years |  Seventh Order of the Jolly Roger - Seven years |  Eighth Order of the Jolly Roger - Eight years |  Ninth Order of the Jolly Roger - Nine years |  Tenth Order of the Jolly Roger - Ten years |
 Eleventh Order of the Jolly Roger - Eleven years |  Twelfth Order of the Jolly Roger - Twelve years |  Thirteenth Order of the Jolly Roger - Thirteen years |  Fourteenth Order of the Jolly Roger - Fourteen years |  Fifteenth Order of the Jolly Roger - Fifteen years |
 Sixteenth Order of the Jolly Roger - Sixteen years |  Seventeenth Order of the Jolly Roger - Seventeen years |  Eighteenth Order of the Jolly Roger - Eighteen years |  Nineteenth Order of the Jolly Roger - Nineteen years |  Twentieth Order of the Jolly Roger - Twenty years |
 Twenty-first Order of the Jolly Roger - Twenty-one years |
| Trophy | Seen on this pirate | % of players | Subcategory | Category | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| #1 Alchemist | - | Crafting trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| #1 Battle Navigator | - | Piracy trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| #1 Bilger | - | Piracy trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| #1 Blacksmith | - | Crafting trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| #1 Carpenter | - | Piracy trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| #1 Distiller | - | Crafting trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| #1 Drinker | - | Carousing trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| #1 Forager | - | Crafting trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| #1 Gunner | - | Piracy trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| #1 Hearts Player | - | Carousing trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| #1 Navigator | - | Piracy trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| #1 Patcher | - | Piracy trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| #1 Poker Player | - | Carousing trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| #1 Rigger | - | Piracy trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| #1 Rumbler | - | Piracy trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| #1 Sailor | - | Piracy trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| #1 Shipwright | - | Crafting trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| #1 Spades Player | - | Carousing trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| #1 Swordfighter | - | Piracy trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| #1 Treasure Drop Player | - | Carousing trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| #1 Treasure Hauler | - | Piracy trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| #1 Weaver | - | Crafting trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| Abandoned Crutch | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| A Collector o' Note Trading in 100 Trinkets at the Trading post. | - | Trinket trading trophies | ||
| A Couple o' Crunchers 20 cookies traded in. | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Adamant Awesomeness | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Adept Swordsman of Sprinkles 5,000 blocks sprinkled | - | Piracy trophies | Other puzzle trophies | |
| Adept Swordsman of Strikes 1,000 swordfight strikes | - | Piracy trophies | Other puzzle trophies | |
| Adorominable Snow Man First yeti doll assembled. | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| A Dozen Daffodils 120 solo portraits commissioned. | - | Miscellaneous trophies | ||
| A Fistful o' Fun 4 toy items assembled. | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| A Good Haul 35 battles won | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| A Healthy Heap o' Happiness 30 toy items assembled. | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| All Day Sucker 1 battle won | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Amethyst Chain n' Pin 500 rumble attacks executed | - | Greedy brigands | Pillaging | |
| A Mighty Strong Cuppa Joe | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| An Avid Collector Trading in 2500 Trinkets at the Trading post. | - | Trinket trading trophies | ||
| Anchored by Chocolate Claiming a Chocolate Box Promotion gift in September 2019. | - | Promotions | Historical trophies | |
| Ancient Sealing Tablet First Ancient Tablet assembled. | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| An Eye for Grain 100 grain bonuses earned | - | Piracy trophies | Other puzzle trophies | |
| A Nice Pile o' Playthings 10 toy items assembled. | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Animalistic Auric Arms 100 sea battles against werewolves won | - | Expeditions | Pillaging | |
| Antediluvian Conch First antediluvian conch opened | - | Miscellaneous trophies | ||
| Apprentice's Stuffing and Paints | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Argent Assembler | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Army of Darkness Win sea battles alongside 1,000 skeletons. | - | Skeletal amulet trophies | Pillaging | |
| Assembled Model Frigate First model ship assembled. | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Astral Anchor 100 constellations completed | - | Piracy trophies | Other puzzle trophies | |
| Atlantean Explorer | - | Sea Monster Hunts | ||
| Atlantean Tablet | - | Sea Monster Hunts | ||
| Aye Think I Can, Aye Think I Can First Loot Train furniture assembled. | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Banana Bandana Bonanza Claiming a Banana Box Promotion gift in May, 2013. | - | Promotions | Historical trophies | |
| Banana Bandana on Nana Claiming a Banana Mystery Box Promotion gift in May 2017. | - | Promotions | Historical trophies | |
| Banana Blade Claiming a Banana Mystery Box Promotion gift in May, 2011. | - | Promotions | Historical trophies | |
| Banana Cabana Claiming a Banana Mystery Box Promotion gift in May 2019. | - | Promotions | Historical trophies | |
| Banana Gettin' a Tanna Claiming a Banana Box Promotion gift in May 2022. | - | Promotions | Historical trophies | |
| Banana Hand Claiming a Banana Mystery Box Promotion gift in May 2018. | - | Promotions | Historical trophies | |
| Banana King Figurine Claiming a Banana Box Promotion gift in May, 2014. | - | Promotions | Historical trophies | |
| Banana on a Pianna Claiming a Banana Box Promotion gift in May 2021. | - | Promotions | Historical trophies | |
| Banana on the Savannah Claiming a Banana Box Promotion gift in May 2020. | - | Promotions | Historical trophies | |
| Banana Pirann-nha Claiming a Banana Box Promotion gift in May 2024. | - | Promotions | Historical trophies | |
| Banana-ramma Claiming a Banana Mystery Box Promotion gift in May 2016. | - | Promotions | Historical trophies | |
| Banana with a Planna Claiming a Banana Box Promotion gift in May 2023. | - | Promotions | Historical trophies | |
| Bandana Full o' Spirit Slime First Ecto-blob won | - | Frays | ||
| Barfly Drinking | - | Missions | ||
| Barrel of Bugaboo Baubles 2500 opponents defeated | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Bashed Shield 200 successful defenses | - | Expeditions | Pillaging | |
| Basket o' Munchies 10 food items assembled. | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Battered Hat Awarded to pirates who perform sailing, rigging, carpentry, patching, and bilging for at least 15 minutes on four of the duty stations and at least 10 minutes on the fifth duty station in a blockade. The puzzling can be done in one or more rounds of the same blockade. The ship must be on the board and able to influence blockade buoys. | - | Blockade trophies | ||
| Battered Shield 50 successful sinking attacks | - | Expeditions | Pillaging | |
| Beach Comber First expedition completed | - | Expeditions | Pillaging | |
| Beach Curiosity Claiming a Tempest Box Promotion gift in June 2020. | - | Promotions | Historical trophies | |
| Beach Plum Claiming a Plum Box Promotion gift in July, 2014. | - | Promotions | Historical trophies | |
| Beast Box Unknown | - | Expeditions | Pillaging | |
| Bejeweled Cannon 100,000 cannons filled | - | Piracy trophies | Other puzzle trophies | |
| Bejeweled Crab 5,000 crabs cleared | - | Piracy trophies | Other puzzle trophies | |
| Bejeweled Tourney Board | - | Reputation | ||
| Bellator's Bane 5 winning swordfights. | - | Atlantis | Sea Monster Hunts | |
| Berzerk Bronze Badge First sea battle against werewolves won | - | Expeditions | Pillaging | |
| Big Bad Bronze Beastie | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Big Bad Broth | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Black Diamond Rumbler 1,000 rumble attacks executed | - | Greedy brigands | Pillaging | |
| Blademaster of Sprinkles 100,000 blocks sprinkled | - | Piracy trophies | Other puzzle trophies | |
| Blademaster of Strikes 20,000 swordfight strikes | - | Piracy trophies | Other puzzle trophies | |
| Blast Monkey First Blast Monkey assembled. | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Blood Box Unknown | - | Expeditions | Pillaging | |
| Bloomin' Skull Claiming a May Mystery Promotion gift in May, 2010. | - | Promotions | Historical trophies | |
| Blossoming Banner Claiming a Spring Green Box Promotion gift in March 2018. | - | Promotions | Historical trophies | |
| Boastful Barrel 10 toys assembled. | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Boat Full o' Spirit Slime 100 Ecto-blobs won | - | Frays | ||
| Boatload o' Fun 100 toys assembled. | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Bodegraven Wheel O' Cheese Dutch Meetup, August 2008 | - | Meetups | Historical trophies | |
| Bold Bronze | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Bone-ana Split Claiming a Banana Box Promotion gift in May, 2012. | - | Promotions | Historical trophies | |
| Bone Brothers Win sea battles alongside 25 skeletons. | - | Skeletal amulet trophies | Pillaging | |
| Bone Head First skull won | - | Frays | ||
| Bone Lute | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Boogeyman's Bounty 750 opponents defeated | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Book of Zombie | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Boom! Headshot 800 Kraken Heads bombed | - | Kraken | Sea Monster Hunts | |
| Bootlicker's Banner | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Boots Full o' Spirit Slime 10 Ecto-blobs won | - | Frays | ||
| Boots of Bilging Sublime or higher experience and Able standing in Bilging. | - | Piracy trophies | Other puzzle trophies | |
| Booty-filled Stocking | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Boreal Bronze | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Bountiful Treat Bowl 113 battles won | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Bowl of Blood 100 kraken's blood won | - | Other pillaging trophies | Pillaging | |
| Bradford Starfish UK Meetup, February 2007 | - | Meetups | Historical trophies | |
| Brass Braid 100 wild pieces used | - | Piracy trophies | Other puzzle trophies | |
| Bribery Box 5,000 PoE won | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Briny Mask | - | Sea Monster Hunts | ||
| Broad Alchemist | - | Crafting trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| Broad Battle Navigator | - | Piracy trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| Broad Bilger | - | Piracy trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| Broad Blacksmith | - | Crafting trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| Broad Carpenter | - | Piracy trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| Broad Distiller | - | Crafting trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| Broad Drinker | - | Carousing trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| Broad Forager | - | Crafting trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| Broad Gunner | - | Piracy trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| Broad Hearts Player | - | Carousing trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| Broad Navigator | - | Piracy trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| Broad Patcher | - | Piracy trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| Broad Poker Player | - | Carousing trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| Broad Rigger | - | Piracy trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| Broad Rumbler | - | Piracy trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| Broad Sailor | - | Piracy trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| Broad Shipwright | - | Crafting trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| Broad Spades Player | - | Carousing trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| Broad Swordfighter | - | Piracy trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| Broad Treasure Drop Player | - | Carousing trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| Broad Treasure Hauler | - | Piracy trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| Broad Weaver | - | Crafting trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| Bronze Adventurer | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Bronze Archelon | - | Atlantis | Sea Monster Hunts | |
| Bronze Badge 10 artefacts assembled. | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Bronze Baghlah | - | Pillaging | ||
| Bronze Baker | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Bronze Bastion Unknown | - | Expeditions | Pillaging | |
| Bronze Bilgegargle | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Bronze Bloodsucker First sea battle against vampirates won | - | Expeditions | Pillaging | |
| Bronze Boar Ham | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Bronze Booties | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Bronze-bound Atlas | - | Reputation | ||
| Bronze Brilliance | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Bronze Bucket o' Shortbread | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Bronze Centaur Kylix | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Bronze Citadel First citadel won | - | Atlantis | Sea Monster Hunts | |
| Bronze Cutter | - | Pillaging | ||
| Bronze Death's Head | - | Brigand Kings | Pillaging | |
| Bronze Dhow | - | Pillaging | ||
| Bronzed Tourney Board | - | Reputation | ||
| Bronzed Zombie Foot | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Bronzed Zombie Hand 100 zombie hands won | - | Frays | ||
| Bronze Eyelet 100 grommets used | - | Piracy trophies | Other puzzle trophies | |
| Bronze Eye of Flame | - | Brigand Kings | Pillaging | |
| Bronze Fanchuan | - | Pillaging | ||
| Bronze Finius Pennant | - | Brigand Kings | Pillaging | |
| Bronze Gauntlet | - | Reputation | ||
| Bronze Ghost Brig | - | Haunted Seas | Sea Monster Hunts | |
| Bronze Ghost Frigate | - | Haunted Seas | Sea Monster Hunts | |
| Bronze Ghost Sloop | - | Haunted Seas | Sea Monster Hunts | |
| Bronze Gingerdead Cookie | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Bronze Gorgonyx | - | Atlantis | Sea Monster Hunts | |
| Bronze Grand Frigate | - | Pillaging | ||
| Bronze Haunted Locket | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Bronze Hourglass | - | Brigand Kings | Pillaging | |
| Bronze Javelin of Procris | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Bronze Jaws | - | Brigand Kings | Pillaging | |
| Bronze Junk | - | Pillaging | ||
| Bronze Longship | - | Pillaging | ||
| Bronze Merchant Brig | - | Pillaging | ||
| Bronze Merchant Galleon | - | Pillaging | ||
| Bronze Nocturne | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Bronze Seal of Madness | - | Brigand Kings | Pillaging | |
| Bronze Self-writing Quill | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Bronze Ship Graveyard First graveyard won | - | Haunted Seas | Sea Monster Hunts | |
| Bronze Sigil | - | Brigand Kings | Pillaging | |
| Bronze Sloop | - | Pillaging | ||
| Bronze Spoon 500 kilograms of chests foraged | - | Expeditions | Pillaging | |
| Bronze Triketos | - | Atlantis | Sea Monster Hunts | |
| Bronze Valkyrie Helm | - | Brigand Kings | Pillaging | |
| Bronze War Brig | - | Pillaging | ||
| Bronze War Frigate | - | Pillaging | ||
| Bronze Xebec | - | Pillaging | ||
| Bronze Zombie | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Brotherhood of the Bronze Pineapple First monkey boat defeated | - | Other pillaging trophies | Pillaging | |
| Bubble Pop 5 battles won | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Bucket o' Loot 35 battles won | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Budding Blade Claiming a Spring Surprise Promotion gift in March, 2010. | - | Promotions | Historical trophies | |
| Bushel of Reindeer Apples | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Cabernet Cutlass Claiming a Wine Box Promotion gift in November 2022. | - | Promotions | Historical trophies | |
| Caloric Overload 100 food items assembled. | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Candy Corn 1 battle won | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Cannon of the Deep 50 expeditions completed | - | Expeditions | Pillaging | |
| Captain's Case Claiming a Wine Box Promotion gift in November 2020. | - | Promotions | Historical trophies | |
| Celestial Sloop 2,500 constellations completed | - | Piracy trophies | Other puzzle trophies | |
| Ceremonial Crystal Seal First Crystal Seal assembled. | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Chalice of Blood 10 kraken's blood won | - | Other pillaging trophies | Pillaging | |
| Champion of Sprinkles 100,000 balls sprinkled | - | Piracy trophies | Other puzzle trophies | |
| Champion of Strikes 20,000 rumble strikes | - | Piracy trophies | Other puzzle trophies | |
| Chest o' the Wildwood Unknown | - | Expeditions | Pillaging | |
| Chilling Chest 1,250 chests hauled | - | Haunted Seas | Sea Monster Hunts | |
| Chiropteran Cask Unknown | - | Expeditions | Pillaging | |
| Choc Full o' Loot Claiming a Chocolate Box Promotion gift in September 2020. | - | Promotions | Historical trophies | |
| Chocolate Doubloons First Chocolate Doubloons assembled. | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Chocolate Harvest Claiming a Chocolate Harvest gift in September, 2011. | - | Promotions | Historical trophies | |
| Choco Shako Claiming a Chocolate Mystery Box Promotion gift in September, 2013. | - | Promotions | Historical trophies | |
| Choco Skull Claiming a Chocolate Box Promotion gift in September 2016. | - | Promotions | Historical trophies | |
| Choctopus Claiming a Chocolate Box Promotion gift in September, 2014. | - | Promotions | Historical trophies | |
| Choklit Chomper Claiming a Chocolate Box Promotion gift in September 2018. | - | Promotions | Historical trophies | |
| Chum Bucket | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Chunk o' Obsidian Claiming a Dark Seas Battle Box Promotion gift in September 2017. | - | Promotions | Historical trophies | |
| Coat of Arms | - | Sea Monster Hunts | ||
| Cobalt Banner Awarded to pirates who were transferred from the Cobalt Ocean to the Cerulean Ocean on 2012-01-31. | - | Miscellaneous historical trophies | Historical trophies | |
| Cocoa-nutty Cocktail Claiming a Chocolate Box Promotion gift in September 2022. | - | Promotions | Historical trophies | |
| Coffin Carpenter Scoring a Frenetic at carpenting | - | Expeditions | Pillaging | |
| Color Guard 500 buoys influenced | - | Blockade trophies | ||
| Common Cook | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Corpse Corps Win sea battles alongside 250 skeletons. | - | Skeletal amulet trophies | Pillaging | |
| Corsair's Chianti Claiming a Wine Box Promotion gift in November 2019. | - | Promotions | Historical trophies | |
| Corsair's Cup Claiming a Wine Box Promotion gift in November 2021. | - | Promotions | Historical trophies | |
| Cracking Crates 30 toys assembled. | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Craftsman's Bronze Chisel | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Cratchit's Raise | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Crimson and Jade Statuette Claiming a July Promotion gift in July, 2009. | - | Promotions | Historical trophies | |
| Crimson Banner Could be claimed by one pirate per account that had a pirate on the Crimson Ocean at the time of the closing announcement. | - | Miscellaneous historical trophies | Historical trophies | |
| Crimson Bill's Plume The Jailbreak | - | Puzzle Pirate Adventures | Historical trophies | |
| Crumpled Helm 50 successful defenses | - | Expeditions | Pillaging | |
| Crystal Cringle Unknown grommets used | - | Piracy trophies | Other puzzle trophies | |
| Cultist Crusher 5 frays won | - | Cursed Isles | Sea Monster Hunts | |
| Cursed Banner Must reach the island. | - | Sea Monster Hunts | ||
| Cursed Forager 500 kilograms of chests foraged | - | Cursed Isles | Sea Monster Hunts | |
| Cutter Bane | - | Flotillas | ||
| Cutter Hunter | - | Flotillas | ||
| Cutter Slayer | - | Flotillas | ||
| Daffodil 10 solo portraits commissioned. | - | Miscellaneous trophies | ||
| Deck Hand 15 league points traveled | - | Pillaging | ||
| Delftware Cannon Dutch Meetup, August 2009 | - | Meetups | Historical trophies | |
| Deliciously Deciduous Claiming a Chocolate Box Promotion gift in September 2023. | - | Promotions | Historical trophies | |
| Dennis Claiming a Wine Mystery Box Promotion gift in November, 2013. | - | Promotions | Historical trophies | |
| Der Hahn von Dornhan German Meetup, August 2019 | - | Meetups | Historical trophies | |
| Detailed Rendering 10 expeditions completed | - | Expeditions | Pillaging | |
| Deviled Eggs 12 dozen (144) eggs loaded | - | Kraken | Sea Monster Hunts | |
| Diamond Baghlah | - | Pillaging | ||
| Diamond Candy Cane | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Diamond Cannon 250,000 cannons filled | - | Piracy trophies | Other puzzle trophies | |
| Diamond Crab 20,000 crabs cleared | - | Piracy trophies | Other puzzle trophies | |
| Diamond Cutter | - | Pillaging | ||
| Diamond Dark-flier 200 sea battles against vampirates won | - | Expeditions | Pillaging | |
| Diamond Dhow | - | Pillaging | ||
| Diamond Fanchuan | - | Pillaging | ||
| Diamond Grand Frigate | - | Pillaging | ||
| Diamond Junk | - | Pillaging | ||
| Diamond Longship | - | Pillaging | ||
| Diamond Merchant Brig | - | Pillaging | ||
| Diamond Merchant Galleon | - | Pillaging | ||
| Diamond Sloop | - | Pillaging | ||
| Diamond Vampirate | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Diamond Vampire Fangs | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Diamond War Brig | - | Pillaging | ||
| Diamond War Frigate | - | Pillaging | ||
| Diamond Xebec | - | Pillaging | ||
| Direwolf's Diamond Device 200 sea battles against werewolves won | - | Expeditions | Pillaging | |
| Dormant Beast | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Dread Masterpiece Contributing in-game art content | - | Game design trophies | ||
| Driftwood First sink | - | Sinking | ||
| Drudge's Rejected Toy Parts | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Drunken Silenus | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Dryad's Silver Lyre | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Dutch Tulip Dutch Meetup, August 2017 | - | Meetups | Historical trophies | |
| Ectoplasm and Cheese on Rye | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Eerie Chest 250 chests hauled | - | Haunted Seas | Sea Monster Hunts | |
| Eggcellent Chocolate Surprise Claiming a Chocolate Box Promotion gift in September, 2015. | - | Promotions | Historical trophies | |
| Eighteenth Order of the Jolly Roger Eighteen years | - | Order of the Jolly Roger | Historical trophies | |
| Eighth Order of the Jolly Roger Eight years | - | Order of the Jolly Roger | Historical trophies | |
| Eldritch Plunder 100 opponents defeated | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Eleventh Order of the Jolly Roger Eleven years | - | Order of the Jolly Roger | Historical trophies | |
| Elite Swordsman of Sprinkles 25,000 blocks sprinkled | - | Piracy trophies | Other puzzle trophies | |
| Elite Swordsman of Strikes 5,000 swordfight strikes | - | Piracy trophies | Other puzzle trophies | |
| Embers of Defeat | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Emerald Astrolabe Claiming a Spring Green Box Promotion gift in March 2022. | - | Promotions | Historical trophies | |
| Emerald Blackjack 5 rumble attacks executed | - | Greedy brigands | Pillaging | |
| Emperor's Vintage | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Enlightened Eradicator 50 frays won | - | Cursed Isles | Sea Monster Hunts | |
| Enlightened Forager 50,000 kilograms of chests foraged | - | Cursed Isles | Sea Monster Hunts | |
| Even Drunker Silenus | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Exalted Alchemist | - | Crafting trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| Exalted Battle Navigator | - | Piracy trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| Exalted Bilger | - | Piracy trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| Exalted Blacksmith | - | Crafting trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| Exalted Carpenter | - | Piracy trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| Exalted Distiller | - | Crafting trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| Exalted Drinker | - | Carousing trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| Exalted Forager | - | Crafting trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| Exalted Gunner | - | Piracy trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| Exalted Hearts Player | - | Carousing trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| Exalted Navigator | - | Piracy trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| Exalted Patcher | - | Piracy trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| Exalted Poker Player | - | Carousing trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| Exalted Rigger | - | Piracy trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| Exalted Rumbler | - | Piracy trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| Exalted Sailor | - | Piracy trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| Exalted Shipwright | - | Crafting trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| Exalted Spades Player | - | Carousing trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| Exalted Swordfighter | - | Piracy trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| Exalted Treasure Drop Player | - | Carousing trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| Exalted Treasure Hauler | - | Piracy trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| Exalted Weaver | - | Crafting trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| Expert Alchemist | - | Crafting trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| Expert Battle Navigator | - | Piracy trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| Expert Bilger | - | Piracy trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| Expert Blacksmith | - | Crafting trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| Expert Carpenter | - | Piracy trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| Expert Distiller | - | Crafting trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| Expert Drinker | - | Carousing trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| Expert Forager | - | Crafting trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| Expert Gunner | - | Piracy trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| Expert Hearts Player | - | Carousing trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| Expert Navigator | - | Piracy trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| Expert Patcher | - | Piracy trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| Expert Poker Player | - | Carousing trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| Expert Rigger | - | Piracy trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| Expert Rumbler | - | Piracy trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| Expert Sailor | - | Piracy trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| Expert Shipwright | - | Crafting trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| Expert Spades Player | - | Carousing trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| Expert Swordfighter | - | Piracy trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| Expert Treasure Drop Player | - | Carousing trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| Expert Treasure Hauler | - | Piracy trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| Expert Weaver | - | Crafting trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| Extensive Equipage 30 kits assembled | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Extra Extra Rare Steak | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Eye of the Zombie | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Fall n' Crossbones Claiming a 2008 Halloween Promotion Bonanza gift in October, 2008. | - | Promotions | Historical trophies | |
| Fang Finagler First vampirate fang won | - | Frays | ||
| Fangtastic! 100 vampirate fangs won | - | Frays | ||
| Fangy Pack 10 vampirate fangs won | - | Frays | ||
| Father Frost's Muffin Tray | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Featherweight of Sprinkles 1,000 balls sprinkled | - | Piracy trophies | Other puzzle trophies | |
| Featherweight of Strikes 200 rumble strikes | - | Piracy trophies | Other puzzle trophies | |
| Fencer Swordfight | - | Missions | ||
| Fezziwig's Punch Bowl | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Fifteenth Order of the Jolly Roger Fifteen years | - | Order of the Jolly Roger | Historical trophies | |
| Fifth Order of the Jolly Roger Five years | - | Order of the Jolly Roger | Historical trophies | |
| Figgy Puddin' on a Silver Platter | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Finders Keepers Losers Weepers 3,000 greedy bots eliminated | - | Greedy brigands | Pillaging | |
| First Gold First gold nugget foraged | - | Crafting trophies | Other puzzle trophies | |
| First Order of the Jolly Roger One year | - | Order of the Jolly Roger | Historical trophies | |
| Fish-gobbler's Golden Guilder | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Fist Full o' Treats 5 battles won | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Flag Bearer 100 buoys influenced | - | Blockade trophies | ||
| Flailing Flan 4 dozen (48) eggs loaded | - | Kraken | Sea Monster Hunts | |
| Flame of Bronze Resolve | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Flame of Gilded Courage | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Flame of Silver Spirit | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Flame of Ultimate Victory | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Flotilla Fanatic 100 ships sunk | - | Flotillas | ||
| Flotilla Fighter 25 ships sunk | - | Flotillas | ||
| Flotilla Freebooter 5 ships sunk | - | Flotillas | ||
| Fourteenth Order of the Jolly Roger Fourteen years | - | Order of the Jolly Roger | Historical trophies | |
| Fourth Order of the Jolly Roger Four years | - | Order of the Jolly Roger | Historical trophies | |
| Fragment of Underdone Potato | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Frenetic Forager Scoring a Frenetic at foraging | - | Cursed Isles | Sea Monster Hunts | |
| Frenzy Rising | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Fresh Zombie Hand First zombie hand won | - | Frays | ||
| Frosted Frigate Claiming an Ice Box Promotion gift in January 2018. | - | Promotions | Historical trophies | |
| Frozen Tricorne Claiming an Ice Box Promotion gift in January 2017. | - | Promotions | Historical trophies | |
| Frozen Yohohogurt Claiming an Ice Box Promotion gift in January 2021. | - | Promotions | Historical trophies | |
| Fudgefoot Print Claiming a Chocolate Box Promotion gift in September 2017. | - | Promotions | Historical trophies | |
| Full Steam Ahead Win a sea battle while playing on Steam, or on the same ship as a Steam user. | - | Miscellaneous trophies | ||
| Fuzzy Freebooter First Hobby Pony furniture assembled. | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Fuzzy Slippers | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Gathering o' Gifts 10 toys assembled. | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Generous Gingies 60 cookies traded in. | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Ghost Fish | - | Sea Monster Hunts | ||
| Ghost Gem 5 opponents defeated | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Ghost Hunter First fray won | - | Frays | ||
| Ghost King's Hoard 2500 opponents defeated | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Ghostly Brass Door Knocker | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Ghost's Bane 100 frays won | - | Frays | ||
| Ghost Slayer 10 frays won | - | Frays | ||
| Ghost's Purse 3 opponents defeated | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Gilded Atlas | - | Reputation | ||
| Gilded Egg Submitting a winning egg design | - | Game design trophies | ||
| Gilded Eternal Hourglass | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Gilded Harpoons | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Gilded Loup Garou 100 tufts of fur won | - | Frays | ||
| Gilded Sanguinary Chalice | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Gilded Seal 100 artefacts assembled. | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Gilded Spirit Board | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Gilded Werewolf Claw | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Gingerbread Sloop First Gingerbread Sloop assembled. | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Glacial Gold | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Glittering Chest 1,250 chests hauled | - | Atlantis | Sea Monster Hunts | |
| Glittering Gold | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Glop o'Glopster Goop Claiming a Tempest Box Promotion gift in August 2022. | - | Promotions | Historical trophies | |
| Gold Baghlah | - | Pillaging | ||
| Gold Cloth Scrap 5 greedy bots eliminated | - | Greedy brigands | Pillaging | |
| Gold Cutter | - | Pillaging | ||
| Gold Death's Head | - | Brigand Kings | Pillaging | |
| Gold Dhow | - | Pillaging | ||
| Gold Digger 100 gold nuggets foraged | - | Crafting trophies | Other puzzle trophies | |
| Golden Archelon | - | Atlantis | Sea Monster Hunts | |
| Golden Cannon 10,000 cannons filled | - | Piracy trophies | Other puzzle trophies | |
| Golden Citadel 100 citadel won | - | Atlantis | Sea Monster Hunts | |
| Golden Crab 1,000 crabs cleared | - | Piracy trophies | Other puzzle trophies | |
| Golden Cup o' Cheer | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Golden Elf Hat | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Golden Gauntlet | - | Reputation | ||
| Golden Ghost Brig | - | Haunted Seas | Sea Monster Hunts | |
| Golden Ghost Frigate | - | Haunted Seas | Sea Monster Hunts | |
| Golden Ghost Sloop | - | Haunted Seas | Sea Monster Hunts | |
| Golden Ghosty Cane | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Golden Gloom-walker 100 sea battles against vampirates won | - | Expeditions | Pillaging | |
| Golden Glyph 100 artefacts assembled. | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Golden Goo-slinger | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Golden Gore-hall Unknown | - | Expeditions | Pillaging | |
| Golden Gorgonyx | - | Atlantis | Sea Monster Hunts | |
| Golden Gourmet | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Golden Greatness | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Golden Grommet Unknown grommets used | - | Piracy trophies | Other puzzle trophies | |
| Golden Leg o' Man | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Golden Pegasus Shield | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Golden Sandals of Hermes | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Golden Ship Graveyard 500 graveyards won | - | Haunted Seas | Sea Monster Hunts | |
| Golden Spade 50,000 kilograms of chests foraged | - | Expeditions | Pillaging | |
| Golden Trailblazer | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Golden Triketos | - | Atlantis | Sea Monster Hunts | |
| Golden Werewolf | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Gold Eye of Flame | - | Brigand Kings | Pillaging | |
| Gold Fanchuan | - | Pillaging | ||
| Gold Finius Pennant | - | Brigand Kings | Pillaging | |
| Gold Grand Frigate | - | Pillaging | ||
| Gold Hourglass | - | Brigand Kings | Pillaging | |
| Gold Jaws | - | Brigand Kings | Pillaging | |
| Gold Junk | - | Pillaging | ||
| Gold Longship | - | Pillaging | ||
| Gold Merchant Brig | - | Pillaging | ||
| Gold Merchant Galleon | - | Pillaging | ||
| Gold Seal of Madness | - | Brigand Kings | Pillaging | |
| Gold Sigil | - | Brigand Kings | Pillaging | |
| Gold Sloop | - | Pillaging | ||
| Gold Tooth 50 greedy bots eliminated | - | Greedy brigands | Pillaging | |
| Gold Tooth n' Patch 300 greedy bots eliminated | - | Greedy brigands | Pillaging | |
| Gold Valkyrie Helm | - | Brigand Kings | Pillaging | |
| Gold War Brig | - | Pillaging | ||
| Gold War Frigate | - | Pillaging | ||
| Gold Xebec | - | Pillaging | ||
| Grain Adept 2,000 grain bonuses earned | - | Piracy trophies | Other puzzle trophies | |
| Grain Guru 5,000 grain bonuses earned | - | Piracy trophies | Other puzzle trophies | |
| Grammas's Hard Candy 113 battles won | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Grape Ape Wine Claiming a Wine Box Promotion gift in November 2016. | - | Promotions | Historical trophies | |
| Greedy Barrager 500 swordfight attacks delivered | - | Greedy brigands | Pillaging | |
| Greedy Handful 5 Lavish Lockers stolen | - | Greedy brigands | Pillaging | |
| Greedy Heap 300 Lavish Lockers stolen | - | Greedy brigands | Pillaging | |
| Greedy Hoard 3,000 Lavish Lockers stolen | - | Greedy brigands | Pillaging | |
| Greedy Lunger 50 swordfight strikes delivered | - | Greedy brigands | Pillaging | |
| Greedy Pile 50 Lavish Lockers stolen | - | Greedy brigands | Pillaging | |
| Greedy Poker 5 swordfight strikes delivered | - | Greedy brigands | Pillaging | |
| Greedy Striker 250 swordfight attacks delivered | - | Greedy brigands | Pillaging | |
| Greedy Sword Stormer 1,000 swordfight attacks delivered | - | Greedy brigands | Pillaging | |
| Greedy Trove 1,000 Lavish Lockers stolen | - | Greedy brigands | Pillaging | |
| Green Grog Claiming a Spring Green Box Promotion gift in March 2020. | - | Promotions | Historical trophies | |
| Green Jack Claiming a Spring Green Mystery Box Promotion gift in March, 2014. | - | Promotions | Historical trophies | |
| Green Spring Claiming a Spring Green Box Promotion gift in March, 2015. | - | Promotions | Historical trophies | |
| Greyghost's Treasure Greyghost's Adventure | - | Puzzle Pirate Adventures | Historical trophies | |
| Greyghost's Treasure Map Pirate Hideout | - | Puzzle Pirate Adventures | Historical trophies | |
| Grog Pop Claiming a Ice Box Promotion gift in January 2022. | - | Promotions | Historical trophies | |
| Growling Golden Gore-spiller | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Gunwhale First Gunwhale assembled. | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Hair of the Dog 25 rumless sea battles which result in a swordfight or rumble. | - | Other pillaging trophies | Pillaging | |
| Hammer and Sharpened Pegleg | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Handful o' Toys 4 toys assembled. | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Hard Boiled 30 dozen (360) eggs loaded | - | Kraken | Sea Monster Hunts | |
| Hardwood Pathfinder | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Hasty Sketch First expedition completed | - | Expeditions | Pillaging | |
| Haunted Chest 50 chests hauled | - | Haunted Seas | Sea Monster Hunts | |
| Head Honcho 100 skulls won | - | Frays | ||
| Head Hunter 10 skulls won | - | Frays | ||
| Hearty Harvest Claiming a Harvest Celebration Promotion gift in November, 2009. | - | Promotions | Historical trophies | |
| Heavenly Hook 1,000 constellations completed | - | Piracy trophies | Other puzzle trophies | |
| Heavyweight of Sprinkles 25,000 balls sprinkled | - | Piracy trophies | Other puzzle trophies | |
| Heavyweight of Strikes 5,000 rumble strikes | - | Piracy trophies | Other puzzle trophies | |
| Here comes ye Cavalry First Pirate Teddy furniture assembled. | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Heroic Hauler Scoring a Frenetic at treasure hauling | - | Expeditions | Pillaging | |
| Herring Bone Haypenny | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Hexed Forager 5,000 kilograms of chests foraged | - | Cursed Isles | Sea Monster Hunts | |
| Hijacked Jewelry 1,000 greedy bots eliminated | - | Greedy brigands | Pillaging | |
| Hijacked Load 10 wins | - | Expeditions | Pillaging | |
| Hit the Showers | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Hoard Bandit 2500 chests/eggs loaded | - | Kraken | Sea Monster Hunts | |
| Hoard Burglar 50 chests/eggs loaded | - | Kraken | Sea Monster Hunts | |
| Hoard Raider 1000 chests/eggs loaded | - | Kraken | Sea Monster Hunts | |
| Hoard Thief 200 chests/eggs loaded | - | Kraken | Sea Monster Hunts | |
| Homunculus Humbler 500 frays won | - | Cursed Isles | Sea Monster Hunts | |
| Horn of Plunder Claiming a Harvest Mystery Box Promotion gift in November, 2010. | - | Promotions | Historical trophies | |
| Hot Co-ho-ho-coa Claiming an Ice Box Promotion gift in January 2019. | - | Promotions | Historical trophies | |
| House o' Bricks | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| House o' Sticks | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| House o' Straw | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Humble Bundle 4 toys assembled. | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Hunter Banner Awarded to pirates who were transferred from the Hunter Ocean to the Emerald Ocean on 2012-01-31. | - | Miscellaneous historical trophies | Historical trophies | |
| Ice Chest Claiming an Ice Box Promotion gift in January, 2016. | - | Promotions | Historical trophies | |
| Ice Skullpture Claiming an Ice Box Promotion gift in January, 2011. | - | Promotions | Historical trophies | |
| Icy Blades Claiming an Ice Box Promotion gift in January, 2014. | - | Promotions | Historical trophies | |
| Icy Hairnet | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Imperial Captain Insignia 50 successful attacks | - | Expeditions | Pillaging | |
| Imperial Colonel Insignia 200 successful attacks | - | Expeditions | Pillaging | |
| Imperial Corporal Insignia 10 successful attacks | - | Expeditions | Pillaging | |
| Imperial Eye Patch | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Imperial Private Insignia First successful attack | - | Expeditions | Pillaging | |
| Incredible Alchemist | - | Crafting trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| Incredible Bilger | - | Piracy trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| Incredible Blacksmith | - | Crafting trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| Incredible Carpenter | - | Piracy trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| Incredible Distiller | - | Crafting trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| Incredible Forager | - | Crafting trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| Incredible Gunner | - | Piracy trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| Incredible Navigator | - | Piracy trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| Incredible Patcher | - | Piracy trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| Incredible Rigger | - | Piracy trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| Incredible Sailor | - | Piracy trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| Incredible Shipwright | - | Crafting trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| Incredible Treasure Hauler | - | Piracy trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| Incredible Weaver | - | Crafting trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| Initialed Ingot | - | Reputation | ||
| Ink splotch 50 inks loaded | - | Kraken | Sea Monster Hunts | |
| Inner Skelly Use a skeletal amulet to transform into a skellie. | - | Skeletal amulet trophies | Pillaging | |
| Iron Coils Excellent Rigging | - | Blockade trophies | ||
| Iron Hammer Excellent Carpentry | - | Blockade trophies | ||
| Iron Pump Excellent Bilging | - | Blockade trophies | ||
| Iron Tackle Excellent Sailing | - | Blockade trophies | ||
| Island Hopper 200 expeditions completed | - | Expeditions | Pillaging | |
| Jack Frost's Egg Blizzarder | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Jack-Tar 200 targets completed | - | Piracy trophies | Other puzzle trophies | |
| Jade Monkey Winning one million PoE in a single pot. | - | Carousing trophies | Other puzzle trophies | |
| Jar of Ectoplasmic Preserves | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Jinxed Idol Unknown criteria (awarded at login time). | - | Miscellaneous trophies | ||
| Jolly Green Roger Claiming a Spring Green Promotion gift in March, 2013. | - | Promotions | Historical trophies | |
| Jolly Shamrocks Claiming a Lucky Box Promotion gift in March, 2011. | - | Promotions | Historical trophies | |
| Journeyman's Silver Saw | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Kraken Bait | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Kraken Skulls 20 Kraken Heads bombed | - | Kraken | Sea Monster Hunts | |
| Krak Head 200 Kraken Heads bombed | - | Kraken | Sea Monster Hunts | |
| Laurel of Poison Ivy | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Laurels of Frostbite | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Laurels of Icy Victory | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Laurels of Victory | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Longship Vanquisher Deal max damage to a longship while on a Viking expedition | - | Expeditions | Pillaging | |
| Loose Seal 4 artefacts assembled. | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Lost Figurehead 200 expeditions completed | - | Expeditions | Pillaging | |
| Lucy's Silver Cameo | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Lunch with Zeus | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Lupine Locker Unknown | - | Expeditions | Pillaging | |
| Lustrous Loop Unknown wild pieces used | - | Piracy trophies | Other puzzle trophies | |
| Magnus Congregor Trading in 25,000 Trinkets at the Trading post. | - | Trinket trading trophies | ||
| Malachite Banner Awarded to pirates who were transferred from the Malachite Ocean to the Meridian Ocean on 2012-01-31. | - | Miscellaneous historical trophies | Historical trophies | |
| Map and Brew Buying 100 drinks for an old salt at an inn. | - | Miscellaneous trophies | ||
| Marauder o' Many Faces Unknown | - | Miscellaneous trophies | ||
| Mariner 500 league points traveled | - | Pillaging | ||
| Masterful Sea Dog 40,000 targets completed | - | Piracy trophies | Other puzzle trophies | |
| Master's Golden Hammer | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Merchant Brig Bane | - | Flotillas | ||
| Merchant Brig Hunter | - | Flotillas | ||
| Merchant Brig Slayer | - | Flotillas | ||
| Merchant Galleon Bane | - | Flotillas | ||
| Merchant Galleon Hunter | - | Flotillas | ||
| Merchant Galleon Slayer | - | Flotillas | ||
| Merrow's Comb Claiming a Spring Green Box Promotion gift in March 2025. | - | Promotions | Historical trophies | |
| Middleweight of Sprinkles 5,000 balls sprinkled | - | Piracy trophies | Other puzzle trophies | |
| Middleweight of Strikes 1,000 rumble strikes | - | Piracy trophies | Other puzzle trophies | |
| Midnight Banner Awarded to pirates who were transferred from the Midnight Ocean to the Cerulean Ocean on 2012-01-31. | - | Miscellaneous historical trophies | Historical trophies | |
| Misleadingly Mundane Monster | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Mister Potato Sled First Mister Potato Sled assembled. | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Monogrammed Ingot | - | Reputation | ||
| Mother's Bonnet First winning fray against the Mother o' Nyght | - | Expeditions | Pillaging | |
| Mug o' Blood First kraken's blood won | - | Other pillaging trophies | Pillaging | |
| Nineteenth Order of the Jolly Roger Nineteen years | - | Order of the Jolly Roger | Historical trophies | |
| Ninth Order of the Jolly Roger Nine years | - | Order of the Jolly Roger | Historical trophies | |
| Nose-glow Wax | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Oaken Token of Bilge 100 tokens earned | - | Bilging | Maneuver tokens | |
| Oaken Token of Carpentry 100 tokens earned | - | Carpentry | Maneuver tokens | |
| Oaken Token of Patching 100 tokens earned | - | Patching | Maneuver tokens | |
| Oaken Token of Rigging 100 tokens earned | - | Rigging | Maneuver tokens | |
| Oaken Token of Sails 100 tokens earned | - | Sailing | Maneuver tokens | |
| Octo Bomber First Octo Bomber assembled. | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Old Glory 1,000 buoys influenced | - | Blockade trophies | ||
| Old Man Winter's Cookie Cutters | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| One-eyed Jack 1 dozen (12) eggs loaded | - | Kraken | Sea Monster Hunts | |
| One-Eyed Maple Claiming an All Hallows' Spooktacular Promotion gift in October, 2009. | - | Promotions | Historical trophies | |
| Oozy Duo 20 goop traded in. | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Oracle's Eternal Flame | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Orca Repellent | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Order of the Golden Banana 100 monkey boats defeated | - | Other pillaging trophies | Pillaging | |
| Ornamental Cabin Elf | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Outdated Calendarrr Claiming an Ice Box Promotion gift in January, 2013. | - | Promotions | Historical trophies | |
| Overflowing Chest 6,250 chests hauled | - | Atlantis | Sea Monster Hunts | |
| Overstuffed Pillowcase 113 battles won | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Oyster Clicking on the tombstone of the Old Man from Oyster Island during an expedition | - | Expeditions | Pillaging | |
| Pale Runner | - | Sea Monster Hunts | ||
| Palm Grease 1,000 PoE won | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Parsnip Patch Doll First Parsnip Patch Doll assembled. | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Pastry Pileup 100 cookies traded in. | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Patchy Provisions 4 kits assembled | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Payoff Purse 30,000 PoE won | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Pea Shooter First toy cannon assembled. | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Penguin Fetish First Penguin Fetish assembled. | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Penguin Phaseal Statue First Penguin Idol assembled. | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Penumbral Pumpkin Claiming a Sinister Box Promotion gift in October 2024. | - | Promotions | Historical trophies | |
| Phantom Fruitcake | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Pile o' Presents 30 toys assembled | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Pilfered Goods First win | - | Expeditions | Pillaging | |
| Pillars of Bilge 100 tokens earned | - | Bilging | Maneuver tokens | |
| Pillars of Carpentry 100 tokens earned | - | Carpentry | Maneuver tokens | |
| Pillars of Patching 100 tokens earned | - | Patching | Maneuver tokens | |
| Pillars of Rigging 100 tokens earned | - | Rigging | Maneuver tokens | |
| Pillars of Sails 100 tokens earned | - | Sailing | Maneuver tokens | |
| Pink Heart Pirates who were greeters on 2006-10-17. | - | Miscellaneous historical trophies | Historical trophies | |
| Pinot Yarrr Claiming a Wine Mystery Box Promotion gift in November, 2012. | - | Promotions | Historical trophies | |
| Pirate Playset First Pirate Playset assembled. | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Pirate Plumder Claiming a Plum Mystery Box Promotion gift in July, 2011. | - | Promotions | Historical trophies | |
| Pirate's Press Claiming a Wine Box Promotion gift in November 2018. | - | Promotions | Historical trophies | |
| Platinum Plait Unknown wild pieces used | - | Piracy trophies | Other puzzle trophies | |
| Platter o' Delights 4 food items assembled. | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Plenty o' Packages 30 toys assembled. | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Plum-bob Quadrant Claiming a Plum Mystery Box Promotion gift in July, 2012. | - | Promotions | Historical trophies | |
| Plum Chewin' Gum Claiming a Plum Box Promotion gift in July 2020. | - | Promotions | Historical trophies | |
| Plum Chum Claiming a Plum Box Promotion gift in July 2021. | - | Promotions | Historical trophies | |
| Plum Chum with a Side o' Rum Claiming a Plum Box Promotion gift in July 2022. | - | Promotions | Historical trophies | |
| Plum Crazy Claiming a Plum Box Promotion gift in July 2018. | - | Promotions | Historical trophies | |
| Plum in the Sun Claiming a Plum Box Promotion gift in July 2016. | - | Promotions | Historical trophies | |
| Plum Rum Claiming a Plum Box Promotion gift in July, 2013. | - | Promotions | Historical trophies | |
| Plumscreen Lotion Claiming a Plum Box Promotion gift in July, 2015. | - | Promotions | Historical trophies | |
| Plum the Depths Claiming a Plum Box Promotion gift in July 2019. | - | Promotions | Historical trophies | |
| Plum Tuckered Out Claiming a Plum Box Promotion gift in July 2017. | - | Promotions | Historical trophies | |
| Plundered Loot 200 wins | - | Expeditions | Pillaging | |
| Pocket Full o' Goodies 5 battles won | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Preserved Zombie Hand 10 zombie hands won | - | Frays | ||
| Primary Pygoscelis | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Prize Holiday Goose | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Proto-diamond | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Puzzlin' with Aplum Claiming a Plum Box Promotion gift in July 2023. | - | Promotions | Historical trophies | |
| Quinquennial Seal o' Piracy Win any five annual Seals o' Piracy. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Radiant Jolly Roger 10,000 constellations completed | - | Piracy trophies | Other puzzle trophies | |
| Realistic Rocking Pony First rocking pony assembled. | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Reef Raider 50 expeditions completed | - | Expeditions | Pillaging | |
| Reindeer Feed | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Renfield's Knickers | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Respectable Replenishment 10 kits assembled | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Resplendent Ring 2,000 grommets used | - | Piracy trophies | Other puzzle trophies | |
| Revenant Rock Receptacle 750 opponents defeated | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Revered Alchemist | - | Crafting trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| Revered Battle Navigator | - | Piracy trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| Revered Bilger | - | Piracy trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| Revered Blacksmith | - | Crafting trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| Revered Carpenter | - | Piracy trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| Revered Distiller | - | Crafting trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| Revered Drinker | - | Carousing trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| Revered Forager | - | Crafting trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| Revered Gunner | - | Piracy trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| Revered Hearts Player | - | Carousing trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| Revered Navigator | - | Piracy trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| Revered Patcher | - | Piracy trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| Revered Poker Player | - | Carousing trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| Revered Rigger | - | Piracy trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| Revered Rumbler | - | Piracy trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| Revered Sailor | - | Piracy trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| Revered Shipwright | - | Crafting trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| Revered Spades Player | - | Carousing trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| Revered Swordfighter | - | Piracy trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| Revered Treasure Drop Player | - | Carousing trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| Revered Treasure Hauler | - | Piracy trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| Revered Weaver | - | Crafting trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| Rites of Spring Claiming a Spring Green Box Promotion gift in March, 2016. | - | Promotions | Historical trophies | |
| Rogue Vintage Claiming a Harvest Mystery Box Promotion gift in November, 2011. | - | Promotions | Historical trophies | |
| Rolling Pin of the Frost Giants | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Roly Poly Fish Bucket | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Rope Knot 5,000 tokens earned | - | Rigging | Maneuver tokens | |
| Rope Seal 10 artefacts assembled. | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Rorschach 250 inks loaded | - | Kraken | Sea Monster Hunts | |
| Ruby Gaff 50 rumble attacks executed | - | Greedy brigands | Pillaging | |
| Rumnog First Rum Nog assembled. | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Rum Pum Pum Rum First small drum assembled. | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Sack of Flight Powder | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Sage Banner Awarded to pirates who were transferred from the Sage Ocean to the Emerald Ocean on 2012-01-31. | - | Miscellaneous historical trophies | Historical trophies | |
| Sailing Rations Kit First sailing rations kit assembled. | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Sanctified Bilge Water | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Sandbar Skipper 10 expeditions completed | - | Expeditions | Pillaging | |
| Sanguinary Seachest Unknown | - | Expeditions | Pillaging | |
| Santa's Sack 100 toys assembled | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Sapphire Brass Knuckles 250 rumble attacks executed | - | Greedy brigands | Pillaging | |
| Savage Majesty | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Savage Silver Signet 25 sea battles against werewolves won | - | Expeditions | Pillaging | |
| Savvy Sailor 4,000 targets completed | - | Piracy trophies | Other puzzle trophies | |
| Scale Model 30 expeditions completed | - | Expeditions | Pillaging | |
| Scrapper Rumble | - | Missions | ||
| Seafarer 30 league points traveled | - | Pillaging | ||
| Sealed the Deal First Imperial outpost defeated. | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Sea Legs Completing 5 missions. | - | Missions | ||
| Seal Fetish First Seal Fetish assembled. | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Seal of Bilge 100 tokens earned | - | Bilging | Maneuver tokens | |
| Seal of Carpentry 100 tokens earned | - | Carpentry | Maneuver tokens | |
| Seal of Ink Unknown number of inks loaded | - | Kraken | Sea Monster Hunts | |
| Seal of Patching 100 tokens earned | - | Patching | Maneuver tokens | |
| Seal of Rigging 100 tokens earned | - | Rigging | Maneuver tokens | |
| Seal of Sails 100 tokens earned | - | Sailing | Maneuver tokens | |
| Seal of the Hammer 17,250 tokens earned | - | Carpentry | Maneuver tokens | |
| Seal of the Pump 17,250 tokens earned | - | Bilging | Maneuver tokens | |
| Seal of the Sheets 17,250 tokens earned | - | Rigging | Maneuver tokens | |
| Seal of the Spool 17,250 tokens earned | - | Patching | Maneuver tokens | |
| Seal of the Tackle 17,250 tokens earned | - | Sailing | Maneuver tokens | |
| Seal o' Piracy: 2009 Win all 2009 seals. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: 2010 Win all 2010 seals. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: 2011 Win all 2011 seals. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: 2012 Win all the 2012 seals. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: 2013 Win all the 2013 seals. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: 2014 Win all the 2014 seals. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: 2015 Win all the 2015 seals. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: 2016 Win all the 2016 seals. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: 2017 Win all the 2017 seals. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: 2018 Win all the 2018 seals. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: 2019 Win all the 2019 seals. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: 2020 Win all the 2020 seals. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: 2021 Win all the 2021 seals. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: 2022 Win all the 2022 seals. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: 2023 Win all the 2023 seals. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: 2024 Win all the 2024 seals. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: April 2010 Complete a session of four different labor puzzles, except Foraging. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: April 2011 Complete twenty-five sea battles. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: April 2012 Visit two of the three Sea Monster locations. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: April 2013 Engage in melees with three Brigand Kings. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: April 2014 Complete three actions that contribute to Explorer reputation. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: April 2015 Engage in melee with 3 Brigand Kings. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: April 2016 Engage in melees with three Brigand Kings. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: April 2017 Complete 3 actions to add to yer explorer reputation! | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: April 2018 Engage in melees with 3 Brigand Kings, win or lose. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: April 2019 Engage in melees with three Brigand Kings. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: April 2020 Complete 3 actions to add to explorer reputation. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: April 2021 Engage in melees with 3 Brigand Kings. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: April 2022 Engage in melees with 3 Brigand Kings. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: April 2023 Complete 3 actions to add to yer explorer reputation. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: April 2024 Engage in melee with 3 Brigand Kings. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy- April 2025 Engage in melee with 3 Brigand Kings. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: August 2009 Complete a challenge for the August 2009 Sweepstakes. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: August 2010 Play any twelve puzzles, except battle navigation. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: August 2011 Complete a session of five different duty puzzles. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: August 2012 Complete twelve parlor game sessions. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: August 2013 Complete four different expeditions | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: August 2014 Complete 10 parlor games. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: August 2015 Complete 10 parlor games. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: August 2016 Complete 4 different expeditions (Imperial Outpost, Viking Defense, Buried Treasure Atoll, Lost Shipwreck, Yeti, Brigand King). | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: August 2017 Complete 10 parlor games. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: August 2018 Complete 10 parlor games. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: August 2019 Complete 4 different expeditions. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: August 2020 Complete 10 parlor games. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: August 2021 Completing 10 parlor games. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: August 2022 Complete 4 different expeditions. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: August 2023 Complete 10 parlor games. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: August 2024 Complete 10 parlor games. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: Autumn 2009 Win the September, October, and November 2009 seals. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: Autumn 2010 Win the September, October, and November 2010 seals. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: Autumn 2011 Win the September, October and November 2011 seals. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: Autumn 2012 Win the September, October and November 2012 seals. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: Autumn 2013 Win the September, October, and November 2013 seals. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: Autumn 2014 Win the September, October, and November 2014 seals. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: Autumn 2015 Win the September, October, and November 2015 seals. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: Autumn 2016 Win the September, October, and November 2016 seals. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: Autumn 2017 Win the September, October, and November 2017 seals. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: Autumn 2018 Win the September, October, and November 2018 seals. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: Autumn 2019 Win the September, October, and November 2019 seals. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: Autumn 2020 Win the September, October, and November 2020 seals. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: Autumn 2021 Win the September, October, and November 2021 seals. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: Autumn 2022 Win the September, October, and November 2022 seals. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: Autumn 2023 Win the September, October, and November 2023 seals. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: Autumn 2024 Win the September, October, and November 2024 seals. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: December 2009 Complete ten expeditions. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: December 2010 Complete a non-Navy session of five different duty puzzles, except Treasure Haul. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: December 2011 Fight in three Brigand King melees at sea. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: December 2012 Complete twenty-five sea battles. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: December 2013 Complete thirty sea battles. Sea battles involving a longship are worth triple. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: December 2014 Complete a non-Navy session of 5 different duty puzzles. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: December 2015 Complete non-Navy sessions of five (5) different duty puzzles. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: December 2016 Complete 30 sea battles. Sea battles involving a Longship (either as your ship or the opponent) count triple! | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: December 2017 Complete a non-Navy session of 5 different duty puzzles. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: December 2018 Complete non-Navy sessions of five (5) different duty puzzles. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: December 2019 Complete 30 sea battles. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: December 2020 Complete a non-Navy session of 5 different duty puzzles. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: December 2021 Completing non-Navy sessions of five different duty puzzles. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: December 2022 Complete 30 sea battles. Longship (yours or opponents) counts triple. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: December 2023 Complete a non-Navy session of 5 different duty puzzles. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: December 2024 Complete a non-Navy session of 5 different duty puzzles. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: February 2010 Visit three of the necessary destinations. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: February 2011 Complete four different expeditions (Brigand Kings and Merchant Hunts don't count) | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: February 2012 Complete a non-Navy session of five different duty puzzles. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: February 2013 Complete any two different expeditions. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: February 2014 Complete one buried treasure expedition. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: February 2015 Complete 2 different expeditions (Imperial, Viking, Buried Treasure, or Shipwreck). | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: February 2016 Complete 2 different expeditions (Imperial Outpost, Viking Defense, Buried Treasure Atoll, or Lost Shipwreck). | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: February 2017 Complete 1 buried treasure expedition. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: February 2018 Complete 2 different expeditions (Imperial Outpost, Viking Defense, Buried Treasure Atoll, or Lost Shipwreck) | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: February 2019 Complete 2 different expeditions. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: February 2020 Complete 1 buried treasure expedition. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: February 2021 Complete 2 different expeditions. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: February 2022 Complete 2 different expeditions. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: February 2023 Complete 1 buried treasure expedition. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: February 2024 Complete 2 different expeditions. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: February 2025 Complete 2 different expeditions. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: January 2010 Complete a session of every parlor/inn game, except poker. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: January 2011 Defeat a group of skellies and zombies once each. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: January 2012 Face ten brigands and ten barbarians in sea battle. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: January 2013 Face ten brigands and ten barbarians in sea battle | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: January 2014 Complete three sea battles involving a junk and three involving a fanchuan. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: January 2015 Complete ten sea battles against brigands, and ten against barbarians. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: January 2016 Complete 10 sea battles against brigands and 10 sea battles against barbarians. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: January 2017 Participate in 3 sea battles involving a Junk and 3 sea battles involving a Fanchuan. (A battle between a Junk and a Fanchuan counts towards both.) | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: January 2018 Complete 10 sea battles against brigands, and 10 sea battles against barbarians | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: January 2019 Complete 10 sea battles against brigands, and 10 sea battles against barbarians. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: January 2020 Participate in 3 sea battles involving a Junk and 3 sea battles involving a Fanchuan. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: January 2021 Complete 10 sea battles against brigands, and 10 sea battles against barbarians. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: January 2022 Complete 10 sea battles against brigands, and 10 sea battles against barbarians. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: January 2023 3 sea battles involving a Junk and 3 sea battles involving a Fanchuan. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: January 2024 Complete 10 sea battles against brigands, and 10 sea battles against barbarians. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: January 2025 Complete 10 sea battles against brigands, and 10 sea battles against barbarians. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: July 2010 Complete thirty sea battles; Battles involving a junk are worth triple. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: July 2011 Visit two of the three Sea Monster locations. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: July 2012 Perform two different actions that earns the pirate in question Conqueror Reputation. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: July 2013 Complete twelve parlor game sessions. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: July 2014 Complete 30 sea battles. Sea battles involving a cutter are worth triple. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: July 2015 Perform 2 different actions that earn your pirate Conqueror Reputation. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: July 2016 Complete 12 parlor game sessions. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: July 2017 Complete 30 sea battles. (Battles involving a cutter count triple.) | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: July 2018 Perform 2 different actions that earn your pirate Conqueror Reputation (Fight BKs, skellies, zombies, or werewolves, or complete IO or Viking raid expeditions.) | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: July 2019 Complete 12 parlor game sessions. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: July 2020 Complete 30 sea battles. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: July 2021 Perform 2 different actions that earns your pirate Conqueror Reputation. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: July 2022 Complete 12 parlor game sessions. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: July 2023 Complete 30 sea battles. Sea battles involving a cutter are worth triple. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: July 2024 Perform 2 different actions that earn your pirate Conqueror Reputation. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: June 2010 Reach the melee in three Brigand King battles at sea. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: June 2011 Complete a session of four labor puzzles. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: June 2012 Perform two different actions that earns the pirate in question Explorer Reputation. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: June 2013 Complete five different duties on a non-Navy vessel. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: June 2014 Complete any five expeditions. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: June 2015 Perform 1 action that earns your pirate Patron Reputation. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: June 2016 Complete a non-Navy session of 5 different duty puzzles. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: June 2017 Complete any 5 expeditions. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: June 2018 Perform 1 action that earns your pirate patron reputation. (There must be at least 10 participants to count.) | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: June 2019 Complete a non-Navy session of 5 different duty puzzles. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: June 2020 Complete any 5 expeditions. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: June 2021 Perform 1 action that earns your pirate Patron Reputation. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: June 2022 Complete a non-Navy session of 5 different duty puzzles. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: June 2023 Complete any 5 expeditions. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: June 2024 Perform 1 action that earns your pirate Patron Reputation. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: March 2010 Complete twenty-five sea battles. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: March 2011 Participate in five tournaments. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: March 2012 Participate in five tournaments. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: March 2013 Participate in five tournaments. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: March 2014 Participate in four tournaments. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: March 2015 Participate in four tournaments. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: March 2016 Participate in five tournaments. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: March 2017 Participate in 4 tournaments | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: March 2018 Participate in four tournaments. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: March 2019 Participate in 5 different tournaments. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: March 2020 Participate in 4 tournaments. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: March 2021 Participate in 4 tournaments. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: March 2022 Participate in 5 tournaments. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: March 2023 Participate in 4 tournaments. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: March 2024 Participate in 4 tournaments. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: March 2025 Participate in 5 tournaments. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: May 2010 Complete a non-Navy session of five different duty puzzles, except Treasure Haul. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: May 2011 Reach the melee in three Brigand King battles at sea. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: May 2012 Perform one action that earns the pirate in question Patron Reputation. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: May 2013 Complete twenty sea battles. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: May 2014 Complete the melee stage of 3 sea battles that involve Brigand Kings. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: May 2015 Complete 20 sea battles. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: May 2016 Complete 20 sea battles. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: May 2017 Engage in melees with 3 Brigand Kings. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: May 2018 Complete 20 sea battles. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: May 2019 Complete 20 sea battles. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: May 2020 Engage in melees with 3 Brigand Kings. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: May 2021 Complete 20 sea battles. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: May 2022 Complete 20 sea battles. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: May 2023 Engage in melees with 3 Brigand Kings or Vampirate Vessels. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: May 2024 Complete 20 sea battles. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: November 2009 Complete a session of six different duty puzzles. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: November 2010 Complete twelve parlor game sessions (poker does not count) | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: November 2011 Complete twelve parlor game sessions (poker does not count) | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: November 2012 Complete a session of four labor puzzles. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: November 2013 Complete a session of four different crafting puzzles. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: November 2014 Completing two foraging sessions outside of the Cursed Isles | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: November 2015 Complete two sessions of foraging. (Cursed Isles foraging does not count.) | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: November 2016 Complete sessions of 4 different crafting puzzles. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: November 2017 Complete 2 sessions of foraging. (Foraging while in Cursed Isles does not count.) | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: November 2018 Complete 2 sessions of foraging. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: November 2019 Complete sessions of 4 different crafting puzzles. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: November 2020 Completing 2 sessions of foraging. (Foraging while in Cursed Isles does not count.) | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: November 2021 Completing 2 foraging sessions. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: November 2022 Complete sessions of 4 different crafting puzzles. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: November 2023 Complete 2 sessions of foraging. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: November 2024 Complete 2 sessions of foraging. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: October 2009 Defeat a group of skellies and zombies once each. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: October 2010 Complete ten sea battles against brigands, and ten against barbarians. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: October 2011 Defeat two of the three monster types in a fray: skellies, zombies, or werewolves. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: October 2012 Defeat two of the three roving monster types (skellies, zombies, and werewolves). | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: October 2013 Defeat one group of skellies and one group of zombies. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: October 2014 Fight the graveyard in Haunted Seas 3 times. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: October 2015 Complete two actions to add to yer explorer reputation. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: October 2016 Defeat 1 group of skellies and 1 group of zombies. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: October 2017 Fight the graveyard in Haunted Seas 3 times, win or lose. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: October 2018 Complete 2 actions that add to your explorer reputation. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: October 2019 Defeat 1 group of skellies and 1 group of zombies. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: October 2020 Fight the graveyard in Haunted Seas 3 times, win or lose. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: October 2021 Perform 2 actions that earn your pirate Eplorer Reputation. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: October 2022 Defeat 1 group of skellies and 1 group of zombies. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: October 2023 Fight the graveyard in Haunted Seas 3 times. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: October 2024 Complete 2 actions to add to yer explorer reputation. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: September 2009 Visit three of the necessary destinations. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: September 2010 Visit four of the necessary destinations. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: September 2011 Complete four different expeditions. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: September 2012 Fight in three Brigand King melees at sea. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: September 2013 Perform two different actions that earn the pirate in question Conqueror Reputation. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: September 2014 Complete one session of 4 different crafting puzzles. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: September 2015 Complete 4 different crafting sessions. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: September 2016 Perform 2 different actions that earn your pirate Conqueror Reputation. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: September 2017 Complete 4 different crafting sessions. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: September 2018 Complete 4 different crafting sessions. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: September 2019 Perform 2 different actions that earn Conqueror Reputation. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: September 2020 Complete 4 different crafting sessions. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: September 2021 Completing 4 different crafting sessions. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: September 2022 Perform 2 different actions that earn your pirate Conqueror Reputation. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: September 2023 Complete 4 different crafting sessions. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: September 2024 Complete 4 different crafting sessions. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: Spring 2010 Win the March, April, and May 2010 seals | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: Spring 2011 Win the March, April, and May 2011 seals. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: Spring 2012 Win the March, April, and May 2012 seals. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: Spring 2013 Win the March, April, and May 2013 seals. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: Spring 2014 Win the March, April, and May 2014 seals. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: Spring 2015 Win the March, April, and May 2015 seals. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: Spring 2016 Win the March, April, and May 2016 seals. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: Spring 2017 Win the March, April, and May 2017 seals. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: Spring 2018 Win the March, April, and May 2018 seals. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: Spring 2019 Win the March, April, and May 2019 seals. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: Spring 2020 Win the March, April, and May 2020 seals. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: Spring 2021 Win the March, April, and May 2021 seals. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: Spring 2022 Win the March, April, and May 2022 seals. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: Spring 2023 Win the March, April, and May 2023 seals. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: Spring 2024 Win the March, April, and May 2024 seals. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: Summer 2010 Win the June, July, and August 2010 seals | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: Summer 2011 Win the June, July, and August 2011 seals | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: Summer 2012 Win the June, July, and August 2012 seals | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: Summer 2013 Win the June, July, and August 2013 seals. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: Summer 2014 Win the June, July, and August 2014 seals. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: Summer 2015 Win the June, July, and August 2015 seals. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: Summer 2016 Win the June, July, and August 2016 seals. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: Summer 2017 Win the June, July, and August 2017 seals. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: Summer 2018 Win the June, July, and August 2018 seals. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: Summer 2019 Win the June, July, and August 2019 seals. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: Summer 2020 Win the June, July, and August 2020 seals. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: Summer 2021 Win the June, July, and August 2021 seals. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: Summer 2022 Win the June, July, and August 2022 seals. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: Summer 2023 Win the June, July, and August 2023 seals. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: Summer 2024 Win the June, July, and August 2024 seals. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: Winter 2010 Win the December 2009, January 2010, and February 2010 seals. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: Winter 2011 Win the December 2010, January 2011, and February 2011 seals. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: Winter 2012 Win the December 2011, January 2012, and February 2012 seals. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: Winter 2013 Win the December 2012, January 2013, and February 2013 seals. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: Winter 2014 Win the December 2013, January 2014, and February 2014 seals. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: Winter 2015 Win the December 2014, January 2015, and February 2015 seals. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: Winter 2016 Win the December 2015, January 2016, and February 2016 seals. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: Winter 2017 Win the December 2016, January 2017, and February 2017 seals. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: Winter 2018 Win the December 2017, January 2018, and February 2018 seals. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: Winter 2019 Win the December 2018, January 2019, and February 2019 seals. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: Winter 2020 Win the December 2019, January 2020, and February 2020 seals. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: Winter 2021 Win the December 2020, January 2021, and February 2021 seals. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: Winter 2022 Win the December 2021, January 2022, and February 2022 seals. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: Winter 2023 Win the December 2022, January 2023, and February 2023 seals. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: Winter 2024 Win the December 2023, January 2024, and February 2024 seals. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Seal o' Piracy: Winter 2025 Win the December 2024, January 2025, and February 2025 seals. | - | Seals o' Piracy | Historical trophies | |
| Sealperial Thumper | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Sea Satyr's Rhyton Claiming a Wine Box Promotion gift in November 2023. | - | Promotions | Historical trophies | |
| Seasoned Old Salt 10,000 targets completed | - | Piracy trophies | Other puzzle trophies | |
| Seattle Bear US Meetup, January 2017 | - | Meetups | Historical trophies | |
| Seattle Totem US Meetup, August 2006 | - | Meetups | Historical trophies | |
| Secondary Spheniscus | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Second Order of the Jolly Roger Two years | - | Order of the Jolly Roger | Historical trophies | |
| Seventeenth Order of the Jolly Roger Seventeen years | - | Order of the Jolly Roger | Historical trophies | |
| Seventh Order of the Jolly Roger Seven years | - | Order of the Jolly Roger | Historical trophies | |
| Shadowberry Skull Claiming a Sinister Box Promotion gift in October 2022. | - | Promotions | Historical trophies | |
| Shark King's Things Claiming a Tempest Box Promotion gift in August 2023. | - | Promotions | Historical trophies | |
| Shattered Swords 10 successful defenses | - | Expeditions | Pillaging | |
| Shining Silver | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Shiny Shapeshifter 10 tufts of fur won | - | Frays | ||
| Ship in a Bottle A welcome trophy for the Opal Ocean, awarded from a PoEmail sent to Indigo Ocean players, but able to be claimed on any ocean. | - | Miscellaneous historical trophies | Historical trophies | |
| Ship Materials Kit First ship materials kit assembled. | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Shivering Silver | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Silver Archelon | - | Atlantis | Sea Monster Hunts | |
| Silver Baghlah | - | Pillaging | ||
| Silver Cannon 1,000 cannons filled | - | Piracy trophies | Other puzzle trophies | |
| Silver Cannon Ball | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Silver Citadel 25 citadels won | - | Atlantis | Sea Monster Hunts | |
| Silver Clattering Chain | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Silver Crab 100 crabs cleared | - | Piracy trophies | Other puzzle trophies | |
| Silver Cutter | - | Pillaging | ||
| Silver Daybed | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Silver Death's Head | - | Brigand Kings | Pillaging | |
| Silver Dhow | - | Pillaging | ||
| Silver Discus of Heracles | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Silver Ecto-cocoa | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Silvered Skellie Bone | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Silvered Whispering Portrait | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Silver Embossed Atlas | - | Reputation | ||
| Silver Explorer | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Silver Eye of Flame | - | Brigand Kings | Pillaging | |
| Silver Fanchuan | - | Pillaging | ||
| Silver Finius Pennant | - | Brigand Kings | Pillaging | |
| Silver Gauntlet | - | Reputation | ||
| Silver Ghost Brig | - | Haunted Seas | Sea Monster Hunts | |
| Silver Ghost Frigate | - | Haunted Seas | Sea Monster Hunts | |
| Silver Ghost Sloop | - | Haunted Seas | Sea Monster Hunts | |
| Silver Gorgonyx | - | Atlantis | Sea Monster Hunts | |
| Silver Grand Frigate | - | Pillaging | ||
| Silver Hourglass | - | Brigand Kings | Pillaging | |
| Silver Jaws | - | Brigand Kings | Pillaging | |
| Silver Junk | - | Pillaging | ||
| Silver Longship | - | Pillaging | ||
| Silver Merchant Brig | - | Pillaging | ||
| Silver Merchant Galleon | - | Pillaging | ||
| Silver Mitten | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Silver Pickaxe 5,000 kilograms of chests foraged | - | Expeditions | Pillaging | |
| Silver Seal of Madness | - | Brigand Kings | Pillaging | |
| Silver Ship Graveyard 50 graveyards won | - | Haunted Seas | Sea Monster Hunts | |
| Silver Sigil | - | Brigand Kings | Pillaging | |
| Silver Skelly | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Silver Sloop | - | Pillaging | ||
| Silver Sludge-meister | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Silver Spyglass | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Silver Stag Haunch | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Silver Strigoi 25 sea battles against vampirates won | - | Expeditions | Pillaging | |
| Silver Stronghold Unknown | - | Expeditions | Pillaging | |
| Silver Superiority | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Silver Triketos | - | Atlantis | Sea Monster Hunts | |
| Silver Valkyrie Helm | - | Brigand Kings | Pillaging | |
| Silver War Brig | - | Pillaging | ||
| Silver War Frigate | - | Pillaging | ||
| Silver Xebec | - | Pillaging | ||
| Simple Sanctum Unknown | - | Expeditions | Pillaging | |
| Single Slime 1 goop traded in. | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Single Snacker 1 cookie traded in. | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Sixteenth Order of the Jolly Roger Sixteen years | - | Order of the Jolly Roger | Historical trophies | |
| Sixth Order of the Jolly Roger Six years | - | Order of the Jolly Roger | Historical trophies | |
| Skeleton Crew Win a sea battle alongside a skeleton | - | Skeletal amulet trophies | Pillaging | |
| Skellie Hunter First fray won | - | Frays | ||
| Skellies' Bane 100 frays won | - | Frays | ||
| Skellie Slayer 10 frays won | - | Frays | ||
| Skelly Grimoire | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Skull n' Crosscones Claiming a Banana Box Promotion gift in July, 2010. | - | Promotions | Historical trophies | |
| Sky-shark Glider First Sky-shark Glider assembled. | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Sleigh Captain | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Slice o' Ice Claiming an Ice Box Promotion gift in January 2020. | - | Promotions | Historical trophies | |
| Slimed Stocking Cap | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Slithery Keepsake Being on a team that sucessfully bombs the Frost Kraken | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Sludge Bucket 60 goop traded in. | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Snarling Silver Scent-stalker | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Snowbeard Avenger Being on a team that sucessfully bombs the Frost Kraken | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Snowbeard's Sleigh 100 toys assembled. | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Snowbeard Victorious | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Snowbeard Victorious 2 | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Snowflake o' Piracy Claiming a Winter Mystery Promotion gift in January, 2010. | - | Promotions | Historical trophies | |
| Snow-ho-ho and a Bottle of Rum! Claiming an Ice Box Promotion gift in January, 2012. | - | Promotions | Historical trophies | |
| Snow Maiden's Spatulas | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Snowy Swashbuckler Claiming an Ice Box Promotion gift in January, 2015. | - | Promotions | Historical trophies | |
| Society of the Silver Coconut 10 monkey boats defeated | - | Other pillaging trophies | Pillaging | |
| Sock Skunky First Sock Skunky assembled. | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Soggy Boot 100 sinks | - | Sinking | ||
| Soggy Chest 50 chests hauled | - | Atlantis | Sea Monster Hunts | |
| Spectre Snacks | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Spires of the Hammer 17,250 tokens earned | - | Carpentry | Maneuver tokens | |
| Spires of the Pump 17,250 tokens earned | - | Bilging | Maneuver tokens | |
| Spires of the Sheets 17,250 tokens earned | - | Rigging | Maneuver tokens | |
| Spires of the Spool 17,250 tokens earned | - | Patching | Maneuver tokens | |
| Spires of the Tackle 17,250 tokens earned | - | Sailing | Maneuver tokens | |
| Spirit Stone Sampler 100 opponents defeated | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Splendid Soutache 2,000 wild pieces used | - | Piracy trophies | Other puzzle trophies | |
| Splintered Axes First successful defense | - | Expeditions | Pillaging | |
| Spring Training Claiming a Lucky Box Promotion gift in March, 2012. | - | Promotions | Historical trophies | |
| Spring Wheel Claiming a Spring Green Box Promotion gift in March 2019. | - | Promotions | Historical trophies | |
| Stamped Ingot | - | Reputation | ||
| Steamed Homunculus | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Steel Coils Incredible Rigging | - | Blockade trophies | ||
| Steel Hammer Incredible Carpentry | - | Blockade trophies | ||
| Steel Pump Incredible Bilging | - | Blockade trophies | ||
| Steel Seal 30 artefacts assembled. | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Steel Tackle Incredible Sailing | - | Blockade trophies | ||
| Sterling Sigil 30 artefacts assembled. | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Sterling Tourney Board | - | Reputation | ||
| Stomped Shako First successful sinking attack | - | Expeditions | Pillaging | |
| Stone Symbol 4 artefacts assembled. | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Subantarctic Silver Dollar | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Sublime Alchemist | - | Crafting trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| Sublime Battle Navigator | - | Piracy trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| Sublime Bilger | - | Piracy trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| Sublime Blacksmith | - | Crafting trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| Sublime Carpenter | - | Piracy trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| Sublime Distiller | - | Crafting trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| Sublime Drinker | - | Carousing trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| Sublime Forager | - | Crafting trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| Sublime Gunner | - | Piracy trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| Sublime Hearts Player | - | Carousing trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| Sublime Navigator | - | Piracy trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| Sublime Patcher | - | Piracy trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| Sublime Poker Player | - | Carousing trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| Sublime Rigger | - | Piracy trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| Sublime Rumbler | - | Piracy trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| Sublime Sailor | - | Piracy trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| Sublime Shipwright | - | Crafting trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| Sublime Spades Player | - | Carousing trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| Sublime Swordfighter | - | Piracy trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| Sublime Treasure Drop Player | - | Carousing trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| Sublime Treasure Hauler | - | Piracy trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| Sublime Weaver | - | Crafting trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| Sugar Plum Found on the Floor | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Sunken Ship's Bell 10 expeditions completed | - | Expeditions | Pillaging | |
| Supreme Stockpile 100 kits assembled | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Survival Supply Kit First survival supply kit assembled. | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Swinging Banana Claiming a Banana Mystery Box Promotion gift in May, 2015. | - | Promotions | Historical trophies | |
| Swiped Cargo 50 wins | - | Expeditions | Pillaging | |
| Swordsman of Sprinkles 1,000 blocks sprinkled | - | Piracy trophies | Other puzzle trophies | |
| Swordsman of Strikes 200 swordfight strikes | - | Piracy trophies | Other puzzle trophies | |
| Tattered Flag 10 successful sinking attacks | - | Expeditions | Pillaging | |
| Tenth Order of the Jolly Roger Ten years | - | Order of the Jolly Roger | Historical trophies | |
| Tertiary Tereingaornis | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| The Call of the Wild | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| The Count's Golden Medallion | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| The Plum Frum Byzantium Claiming a Plum Box Promotion gift in July 2024. | - | Promotions | Historical trophies | |
| Third Order of the Jolly Roger Three years | - | Order of the Jolly Roger | Historical trophies | |
| Thirteenth Order of the Jolly Roger Thirteen years | - | Order of the Jolly Roger | Historical trophies | |
| Thread ball 5,000 tokens earned | - | Patching | Maneuver tokens | |
| Tinted Spectacles | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Toady's Treasure Trove 112,000 PoE won | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Token of Rope 5,000 tokens earned | - | Rigging | Maneuver tokens | |
| Token of the Hammer 17,250 tokens earned | - | Carpentry | Maneuver tokens | |
| Token of the Pump 17,250 tokens earned | - | Bilging | Maneuver tokens | |
| Token of the Sheets 17,250 tokens earned | - | Rigging | Maneuver tokens | |
| Token of the Spool 17,250 tokens earned | - | Patching | Maneuver tokens | |
| Token of the Tackle 17,250 tokens earned | - | Sailing | Maneuver tokens | |
| Token of Thread 5,000 tokens earned | - | Patching | Maneuver tokens | |
| Token of Water 5,000 tokens earned | - | Bilging | Maneuver tokens | |
| Token of Wind 5,000 tokens earned | - | Sailing | Maneuver tokens | |
| Token of Wood 5,000 tokens earned | - | Carpentry | Maneuver tokens | |
| Toppled Crown 200 successful sinking attacks | - | Expeditions | Pillaging | |
| Torch and Trident | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Towers of Rope 5,000 tokens earned | - | Rigging | Maneuver tokens | |
| Towers of Thread 5,000 tokens earned | - | Patching | Maneuver tokens | |
| Towers of Water 5,000 tokens earned | - | Bilging | Maneuver tokens | |
| Towers of Wind 5,000 tokens earned | - | Sailing | Maneuver tokens | |
| Towers of Wood 5,000 tokens earned | - | Carpentry | Maneuver tokens | |
| Toy Bounty 10 toys assembled | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Toy Collection 4 toys assembled | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Toy Soldier Scout First Toy Soldier Scout assembled. | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Toytastic Truckload 100 toy items assembled. | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Transcendent Alchemist | - | Crafting trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| Transcendent Battle Navigator | - | Piracy trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| Transcendent Bilger | - | Piracy trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| Transcendent Blacksmith | - | Crafting trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| Transcendent Carpenter | - | Piracy trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| Transcendent Distiller | - | Crafting trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| Transcendent Drinker | - | Carousing trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| Transcendent Forager | - | Crafting trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| Transcendent Gunner | - | Piracy trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| Transcendent Hearts Player | - | Carousing trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| Transcendent Navigator | - | Piracy trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| Transcendent Patcher | - | Piracy trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| Transcendent Poker Player | - | Carousing trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| Transcendent Rigger | - | Piracy trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| Transcendent Rumbler | - | Piracy trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| Transcendent Sailor | - | Piracy trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| Transcendent Shipwright | - | Crafting trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| Transcendent Spades Player | - | Carousing trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| Transcendent Swordfighter | - | Piracy trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| Transcendent Treasure Drop Player | - | Carousing trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| Transcendent Treasure Hauler | - | Piracy trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| Transcendent Weaver | - | Crafting trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| Tub o'Goo 100 goop traded in. | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Tub o' Tastiness 30 food items assembled. | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Tufted Wolf-Wear First tuft of fur won | - | Frays | ||
| Twelfth Order of the Jolly Roger Twelve years | - | Order of the Jolly Roger | Historical trophies | |
| Twentieth Order of the Jolly Roger Twenty years | - | Order of the Jolly Roger | Historical trophies | |
| Twenty-first Order of the Jolly Roger Twenty-one years | - | Order of the Jolly Roger | Historical trophies | |
| Tyme fer Wyne Claiming a Wine Box Promotion gift in November 2024. | - | Promotions | Historical trophies | |
| Ultimate Alchemist | - | Crafting trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| Ultimate Battle Navigator | - | Piracy trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| Ultimate Bilger | - | Piracy trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| Ultimate Blacksmith | - | Crafting trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| Ultimate Carouser All ultimate carousing trophies | - | Standardized puzzle trophies | ||
| Ultimate Carpenter | - | Piracy trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| Ultimate Crafter All ultimate crafting trophies | - | Standardized puzzle trophies | ||
| Ultimate Distiller | - | Crafting trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| Ultimate Drinker | - | Carousing trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| Ultimate Forager | - | Crafting trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| Ultimate Gunner | - | Piracy trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| Ultimate Hearts Player | - | Carousing trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| Ultimate Navigator | - | Piracy trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| Ultimate of Ultimates Ultimate Pirate, Ultimate Carouser, and Ultimate Crafter. | - | Standardized puzzle trophies | ||
| Ultimate Patcher | - | Piracy trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| Ultimate Pirate All ultimate piracy trophies | - | Standardized puzzle trophies | ||
| Ultimate Poker Player | - | Carousing trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| Ultimate Rigger | - | Piracy trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| Ultimate Rumbler | - | Piracy trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| Ultimate Sailor | - | Piracy trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| Ultimate Shipwright | - | Crafting trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| Ultimate Spades Player | - | Carousing trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| Ultimate Swordfighter | - | Piracy trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| Ultimate Treasure Drop Player | - | Carousing trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| Ultimate Treasure Hauler | - | Piracy trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| Ultimate Weaver | - | Crafting trophies | Standardized puzzle trophies | |
| Unchiseled Potential Substantial participation in the Grand Crafting Puzzle Project. | - | Miscellaneous historical trophies | Historical trophies | |
| Undead Nunchaku | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Unearthly Chest 6,250 chests hauled | - | Haunted Seas | Sea Monster Hunts | |
| Unwrapped Imperial Soldier First toy imperial soldier assembled. | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Valuable Chest 250 chests hauled | - | Atlantis | Sea Monster Hunts | |
| Vampirate Hunter First fray won | - | Frays | ||
| Vampirate's Bane 100 frays won | - | Frays | ||
| Vampirate Slayer 10 frays won | - | Frays | ||
| Vampiric Signet Ring | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Van Helsing's Bronze Hammer | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Vargas Vanquisher First winning fray against Vargas the Mad | - | Cursed Isles | Sea Monster Hunts | |
| Vegas Dice US Meetup, July 2007 | - | Meetups | Historical trophies | |
| Victory Banner 5,000 buoys influenced | - | Blockade trophies | ||
| Vinyarrrd Fresh Claiming a Wine Box Promotion gift in November, 2015. | - | Promotions | Historical trophies | |
| Viridian Banner Awarded to pirates who were transferred from the Viridian Ocean to the Meridian Ocean on 2012-01-31. | - | Miscellaneous historical trophies | Historical trophies | |
| Waterlogged Spyglass First expedition completed | - | Expeditions | Pillaging | |
| Water Marble 5,000 tokens earned | - | Bilging | Maneuver tokens | |
| Wax Fangs | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Weathered Helm Awarded to pirates at the helm of a ship for 50% of a blockade round, whether on the sea battle board or doing other duties while at the helm. The ship must be on the board and able to influence blockade buoys. | - | Blockade trophies | ||
| Wee Lolly 35 battles won | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Werewolf Hunter First fray won | - | Frays | ||
| Werewolf's Bane 100 frays won | - | Frays | ||
| Werewolf Slayer 10 frays won | - | Frays | ||
| Whinin' Cheese Claiming a Wine Mystery Box Promotion gift in November, 2014. | - | Promotions | Historical trophies | |
| Wind Marble 5,000 tokens earned | - | Sailing | Maneuver tokens | |
| Winged Shoes 1,000 whisks from whisking potions. | - | Miscellaneous trophies | ||
| Winkin' Flittermouse Claiming a Sinister Box Promotion gift in October 2021. | - | Promotions | Historical trophies | |
| Wizard of Woodgrain 20,000 grain bonuses earned | - | Piracy trophies | Other puzzle trophies | |
| Wolfsbane Puddin' | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Wooden Stair 5,000 tokens earned | - | Carpentry | Maneuver tokens | |
| X Marks the Spot Awarded to pirates who claimed a Decennium Box between late October and early November, 2012. | - | Miscellaneous historical trophies | Historical trophies | |
| X'Ukara Statue First X'ukara Statue assembled. | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Ye Bronze Bits n' Pieces | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Ye Choklit Raider Claiming a Chocolate Box Promotion gift in September 2021. | - | Promotions | Historical trophies | |
| Ye Cocoa Carp Claiming a Chocolate Box Promotion gift in September 2024. | - | Promotions | Historical trophies | |
| Ye Colorful Draught Claiming a Spring Green Box Promotion gift in March 2024. | - | Promotions | Historical trophies | |
| Ye Darkling Gull Claiming a Sinister Box Promotion gift in October 2023. | - | Promotions | Historical trophies | |
| Ye Diamond Potato | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Ye Dread Sprout Claiming a Spring Green Box Promotion gift in March 2017. | - | Promotions | Historical trophies | |
| Ye Golden Chained Saw | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Ye Golden Parsnip | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Ye Green Cap'n Claiming a Spring Green Box Promotion gift in March 2021. | - | Promotions | Historical trophies | |
| Ye Ice Cap'n Claiming a Ice Box Promotion gift in January 2024. | - | Promotions | Historical trophies | |
| Ye Jolly Campfire Dutch Meetup, July 2013 | - | Meetups | Historical trophies | |
| Ye Jolly Snowball Claiming a Ice Box Promotion gift in January 2023. | - | Promotions | Historical trophies | |
| Ye Jolly Taffy 1 battle won | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Ye Laughing Pooka Claiming a Spring Green Box Promotion gift in March 2023. | - | Promotions | Historical trophies | |
| Ye Olde Harvest Moon Claiming a Chocolate Mystery Box Promotion gift in September to October, 2010. | - | Promotions | Historical trophies | |
| Ye Olde Weevily Biscuit | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Ye Royal Bilge Bucket | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Ye Salty Picaroon Claiming a Tempest Box Promotion gift in August 2024. | - | Promotions | Historical trophies | |
| Ye Silver Sock | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Ye Snowy Sailfish Claiming a Ice Box Promotion gift in January 2025. | - | Promotions | Historical trophies | |
| Yeti's Soiled Apron | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Yococoa Cake Claiming a Chocolate Mystery Box Promotion gift in September, 2012. | - | Promotions | Historical trophies | |
| Yohoho and a Jug o' Merlot Claiming a Wine Box Promotion gift in November 2017. | - | Promotions | Historical trophies | |
| Zombie Chowder | - | Competitions | Historical trophies | |
| Zombie Hunter First fray won | - | Frays | ||
| Zombies' Bane 100 frays won | - | Frays | ||
| Zombie Slayer 10 frays won | - | Frays | ||
